The Invisible Company That Got 200 Websites Hacked

A company most people have never heard of

turned nearly two hundred major websites

malicious,

big changes around the corner for Android

phones,

and a surprising way your data might get

shared that we don't normally think about.

All this and more coming up on This

Week in Privacy Eighty, so stay tuned.

Welcome back to This Week in Privacy,

our weekly series where we discuss the

latest updates with what we're working on

in the Privacy Guides community and this

week's top stories in data privacy and

cybersecurity while answering viewer

questions.

I am Nate,

and with me this week is Jordan.

How are you doing, Jordan?

I'm doing great,

and I'm also super excited to jump into

the stories this week.

Yeah, it was a pretty busy week.

Lots of interesting stuff.

I guess we'll just kind of hop right

into it.

We'll start off here with our first story

from Ars Technica,

which says hundreds of websites deliver

potent malware cocktail to unsuspecting

visitors.

So this was identified by a company called

Report URI, which...

To be honest,

I don't know too much about them.

I know they're some kind of a

cybersecurity website.

They said that they identified a hundred

and seventy eight websites, including CNN,

Zoom, the BBC and Salesforce.

And I saw other websites listed things

like Ikea.

They said.

JavaScript digitally signed by Optimizely

and then loaded into customer pages had

been modified to include malicious

components that attempted to infect

visitor devices with multiple payloads.

When wares were installed successfully,

they swapped user cryptocurrency wallet

addresses for the attackers.

Other components skimmed payment cards,

stole cookies and screenshots,

and on iPhones and iPads delivered iOS

exploit kits known as Karuna and Dark

Sword.

So Optimizely is a,

from what I can understand,

they're kind of an AB testing website.

And also just hello to everyone popping

into the chat.

So nice to see you.

Thank you for coming.

But yeah, Optimizely is a website.

They're not really specifically analytics

in the sense of like Google Analytics,

but they're more designed to AB testing.

So as a real quick example, I remember...

actually I think around this time last

year,

there was a big controversy because people

were seeing different prices when they

went to Proton's webpage.

And people thought maybe Proton was like

using personal data to like do the

surveillance pricing thing.

And Proton was like, no,

it's just a standard AB test.

Um,

but I guess it was showing up kind

of weird for some reason.

It was like showing up, uh,

when it wasn't supposed to yet.

Like it was a black Friday sale that

was lingering too long or something.

So optimizely would be that sort of thing.

I'm not saying they used optimizely,

but it's, it's that thing where like, oh,

this person sees this page,

but this person sees a different version

and we see how people react to it.

Okay, getting back to the story.

It says the JavaScript,

which can be served directly from

Optimizely or from a customer endpoint,

runs on every page the customer serves.

Somehow the attackers wrote their own code

into a portion of each affected customer's

JavaScript and then delivered from

cdn.optimizely.com,

a valid certificate for that domain signed

at the JavaScript.

A researcher said the delivery mechanism

wasn't a CDN cache poisoning attack,

which uses HTTP to cause a CDN to

cache harmful responses.

Instead,

the attacker relied on Optimizely's

legitimate infrastructure,

including its domains,

to serve the tainted code.

Optimizely's own JavaScript for

optimizely.com and login.optimizely.com

URLs were also affected.

At the moment,

there's no information on how successful

the exploit chains were in installing the

payloads beyond the bare bones details and

more precise information about what

versions of iOS were susceptible are also

unavailable at this time.

And the article says these sorts of gaps

are common in breaking news covering mass

malware attacks because it takes time for

researchers to sift through the evidence.

Readers are encouraged to check back as

new developments come to light.

So...

Yeah,

I'll kind of scroll through the article a

little bit here.

There's a lot more technical detail in

here.

And we will definitely be updating you

guys as we learn more.

But yeah, I mean,

that's kind of it for the details of

the story.

So I'll go ahead and bring Jordan back

here.

But it's this,

this is an interesting story,

because how I guess,

Jordan kind of throwing it over to you,

like,

would an ad blocker have worked against

this?

Do you think to defend users?

I mean,

I guess we would have to think about

whether the uBlock origin actually would

have a blocking script.

It would block the actual script that was

malicious in the first place,

which I would assume it's possible.

It's certainly possible.

At least at this point,

it's definitely possible, right?

Because this is known in the wild being

exploited, right?

So possibly...

It's definitely possible.

But again,

I don't think relying on a single defense

is really the best way to protect against

this sort of thing.

I think...

The biggest thing that people were trying

to get from this, like,

hack was people's crypto wallets.

And I think the main thing with that

is just making sure that you don't have

your crypto wallet on the same device as

one that you're using to browse random

websites.

Like, I mean,

these weren't random websites per se,

right?

We're talking about, like you said, CNN,

Zoom, BBC.

Like, these are all, like,

pretty big websites that you wouldn't

expect has malicious JavaScript, right?

So...

But it always goes back to that thing

where we talk about compartmentalization,

especially when it comes to cryptocurrency

and these sort of sensitive things where

if your device is compromised,

that information will definitely be

stolen.

So if you're using a device for browsing

news websites and random websites that you

know

possibly might not be as secure and they

might be using some sort of third party

CDN or like in Optimizely case, like,

you know,

some sort of service to basically AB test

certain aspects of the website, then,

you know,

you should probably do that on a separate

device because this is where we find this

sort of, these sort of issues, right?

or use a separate browser as well.

I think using a separate browser is some

sort of defense against this,

but not the most powerful

compartmentalization.

Yeah, for sure.

I don't know if another browser would have

worked.

I thought of that too.

I know, according to my research,

uBlock Origin probably would have blocked

this because Optimizely is a well-known,

they consider it analytics and so they

block it.

But yeah, I mean, that's definitely,

like you said, defense in depth for sure.

I don't think that's the only thing,

but the thing that makes this attack so

interesting is that

it's not from what we can tell so

far it's not like somebody got hacked you

know it's like they said it wasn't like

a dns cache thing it wasn't like a

um you know optimizely is still

investigating they haven't really issued a

statement but we don't know if like

somebody hacked their infrastructure and

planted this malicious code or found a way

to inject this malicious code but either

way like everything looked above board as

far as your computer was concerned like

everything was signed everything came from

the right domains

And so yeah, it's really tricky stuff.

And that's why you are absolutely right

with the defense in depth thing.

One thing I did read when I was

trying to come up with some maybe

potential takeaways was like,

you mentioned the crypto wallets.

Take this with a grain of salt.

I don't know how accurate this is because

I'm not super into the crypto space.

But one advice I read is to check

just like the first few and end,

because it's kind of hard to check like

the whole crypto address, right?

And make sure it's matches note for note.

But because crypto addresses are like

randomly generated,

They're probably going to be very,

very different, usually,

unless it's an extremely sophisticated

attack.

So if you check the first couple of

letters and the last couple of letters,

letters and numbers,

usually that should be enough that you'll

notice, like, okay,

the one I'm trying to send to you

ends with one, two, three, four, five,

and the one that I just pasted ends

in five, four, three, two, one.

Like, hold on, that's way different.

So...

um yeah and then i i do feel

the need to point out uh you know

updates because um i don't know if it

was in the the segment that i read

but it said that the payload that was

delivered to iphones and ipads was karuna

and dark sword which i believe we've

talked about before i know i've definitely

seen those pop up before and those are

i think the last version of ios that

they work on is like ios

be fair that's not super old because i

think that's right about the time that

apple switched to doing like year numbers

instead of numerical numbers um so it's

not like oh my god that was almost

ten versions ago but you know point being

is like it's been patched it's been fixed

and if you keep your stuff updated then

those wouldn't work on your device to

begin with so yeah um defense in depth

for sure um yeah i don't know is

there any uh anything else i missed on

that story that you wanted to add

I think every single person that always

blocks JavaScript is smiling very widely

right now.

Yeah.

I think we talked about that the other

week, right?

Somebody asked about that and it's a pain

to do.

yeah, I mean, it paid off right now,

right?

So yeah,

I think that is one thing that I

think people should take away from this is

try to assume that every website that you

visit, you know,

could possibly have malicious code on it,

right?

Because like we saw in the story,

you know, CNN, Zoom, the BBC,

like Salesforce,

like all these websites that you would

assume when you visit them are safe,

right?

But it's better to, you know,

assume that there's a possibility that the

the website is infected, right?

And use uBlock origin,

like deny JavaScript if possible.

And yeah,

it's just frustrating that this happened

to so many websites and it's probably

going to affect a lot of people because,

you know, when it's so many websites,

the scale of the attack becomes quite

large.

So yeah,

it's really unfortunate for people that

got hacked here,

but also just

I think it's one thing that people that

run websites should take away from this.

Cut down on third-party scripts.

Cut down on third-party services that your

website is using.

Because every time you add one of those

extra parties,

it's adding another level of risk to your

customers.

And we've gotten to a point where the

web has become quite bloated.

If you go to any of these websites,

I'm sure it's loading at least three or

four different external JavaScript

bits of JavaScript code every single time,

right?

So, you know,

it might be useful in some cases to

have these extra, you know,

analytics tools and things,

but it does introduce risks of, you know,

adding potential malicious code because,

you know, if these companies get hacked,

which we don't know at this point whether

they were hacked or not,

but whenever you add an extra party to

your website,

you're trusting them also with your users.

So,

Yeah, it's frustrating,

but also I think we're going to see

this more and more.

I did notice that this company seemed,

I don't want to like bring this back

to AI again,

but this company seems pretty heavy in on

AI.

And I wouldn't be surprised if, you know,

they're trying to move very fast.

They're trying to add features.

They're trying to, you know,

expand the company and possibly something

slipped through that allowed someone to do

this.

So I think it's always good to be

careful,

especially if you're someone that runs a

website, you know,

try and keep everything just hosted

yourself.

Don't trust another company with a bunch

of these extra things.

Yeah, I know over on my website,

there were a couple of volunteers that

volunteered to redo it because it used to

be really,

you probably saw it back in the day.

It used to be just all HTML and

CSS.

I hand coded everything.

And I know enough to get a website

up and running,

but it definitely didn't look great.

It had a lot of room for improvement.

And a couple of volunteers hit me up

and were like, hey,

we really like what you're doing.

We're willing to like redo this.

And the screenshots they sent me,

like the mock-up was so good.

I was like, oh crap,

I have to talk to these people because

I don't like getting cold emails,

but I was like, okay,

this looks really good, actually.

I should talk to these people.

And I remember telling them, I'm like,

rule number one, no JavaScript.

It doesn't need it.

It's just a static website.

And even to this day,

I tweaked it the other day to allow

embeds for videos.

I'm trying to make it more visually

interesting.

And I love how it kind of reminded

me,

the tool I was working with was like,

every domain you whitelist is a trusted

domain that if something malicious goes on

that end,

It's going to filter into your website.

And in that particular case,

I was actually adding one of the privacy

guides videos.

And I'm just like,

I think I trust Jonah.

I think I'll be OK.

But yeah, that was the same thing.

It's every little third party thing you

bring in.

It's just another attack surface.

Um,

I think we can turn that one over

to the viewers.

If there's any defenses that we missed

that you guys think, um,

what do you think was behind this?

Cause I,

I know it's speculation at this point,

but you know, I,

I like to speculate sometimes,

like we don't know who did this.

We don't know what their goal was other

than trying to get crypto.

So now that those words come out of

my mouth, my money says North Korea,

this is the kind of thing they do,

but I don't have any sort of educated

guess on that, by the way,

I'm just throwing around random names,

but, uh, yeah.

What do you guys think was behind this

and what were they trying to do?

But.

We had a couple of quick comments before

we move on to the next one.

Somebody said they like my haircut,

which is funny because I actually haven't

shaved my hair today yet.

So technically,

I do have more hair than usual.

And somebody else said,

all the hosts have good haircuts.

So somebody here asked, oh,

because I was talking about the wallet and

double-checked the wallet.

What if it's still displayed correct in

the confirmation, but in the post,

the attackers changed it?

I mean, that's pretty advanced.

And yeah,

I'm not going to rule it out,

which is why I didn't say that's a

perfect defense.

It's definitely not a perfect defense.

But I mean,

if you're savvy enough to recognize the

terminal, maybe...

Well, I mean,

it would probably be a pain to send

a little bit of crypto to see if

it changes, but I mean, yeah, for sure.

I don't know if I have a defense

against that that's realistic, but yeah,

that's why I didn't say it's a perfect

defense.

It's just like another layer.

If you have a defense against that,

by all means, let me know.

If that's all we got,

I've been keeping an eye on the forum

and stuff,

and I haven't seen any questions pop up

yet.

Sounds good.

I guess we can jump into the next

story here.

Did you say something just then?

There's something in the signal chat.

Actually, yeah, let's see what this is.

Encryption relies on a kind of NP problem

involving prime numbers.

If Anthropic's recent proof of the Ryman

hypothesis is valid,

would encryption be broken?

All right, that goes way above my head,

and I'm not even going to try to

answer it.

Yeah,

I think this is definitely one of these

stories that I've seen during the rounds,

but it's something that we would have to

look into more to actually offer a good

analysis of because...

as Nate said, it is kind of complex.

I haven't even read any of Anthropic's

research on this before.

Whether something can be cracked,

like encryption and stuff,

we've done videos on quantum computing and

stuff like that.

I don't know how it relates to that

specific question, though.

It's definitely something interesting,

and if it ends up being something that

becomes a big story,

I'm sure we'll cover it on the show

at some point,

but I'm sorry we couldn't give you a

better answer.

It's just

it would be something we would have to

look into a bit more in depth before

we answer.

Well,

it looks like it just came out today.

So yeah,

this hasn't even come across my newsfeed

yet,

but here's an article from Scientific

American.

Anthropic mathematician claims to prove

Ryman hypothesis,

most famous problem in all of math.

Wow.

So yeah,

I'll try to remember to read that later

myself.

That definitely sounds interesting.

I don't know anything about it.

This is my first time hearing,

but big if true, I'll say that.

Definitely.

And I think just to put like a

peek behind the scenes a little bit,

we are like putting stories into this

document like pretty like throughout the

entire week.

But we usually try not to put something

in like if it's literally on the day,

we usually try not to just because,

you know,

it doesn't give us time to actually look

at the articles and stuff.

But if it ends up being kind of

a big story,

we can definitely cover it next week.

especially if there's some more

interesting things that come out about

definitely like experts in the field,

if they have any thoughts and stuff.

So we will keep an eye on that

for then.

But I guess for now we will pivot

to the forum discussion that's next on the

show notes.

And that's Codeberg has vanished from the

internet and its team says that the

registrar suspended the domain without

warning.

Codeberg is back now and his selected

piece,

pieces from their official postmortem.

In the European morning of November

eighteenth at around eight thirty CET,

we noticed that our domain did not resolve

any longer.

And when we checked with our domain

register named Silo,

we saw that the domain was completely gone

from the account.

We double checked that our domain was

correctly renewed and that no unauthorized

logins into our account had happened and

check both our abuse at Codeburg email

address and one dedicated for the name

silo account for potential reports slash

information from name silo.

Finding nothing,

we contacted their support at nine fifteen

CET,

which forwarded us to the abuse

department.

At around twelve or five CET,

our domain reappeared in the NameSilo

interface and became technically active

again.

Only at fourteen thirty CET,

we received a response from the abuse

department of NameSilo explaining the

client hold with two abuse cases.

The first case was a project that was

reported to us in twenty twenty two for

which we disputed the abuse case.

The repository in question had already

been archived without further activity

since twenty twenty three.

The second abuse case indeed contained

malware and belonged to an account created

on November,

but which had not been reported to Coburg

via our abuse email address or in any

other way.

Instead,

it appears the person reported the abuse

directly to our domain registrar who then

acted without informing us.

Following the response from NameSilo,

we have removed the two repositories in

question,

and we are disappointed that NameSilo has

held our domain without informing our team

or proactively forwarding the abuse

report,

which would have allowed our moderation

team to act.

We've reached out to NameSilo to assure we

can avoid this situation in the future.

We have received multiple friendly offers

from domain registrars to migrate our

domain to them.

We are very grateful for this,

and we will evaluate them soon.

Additionally,

our infrastructure team is exploring the

use of a secondary domain name.

In fact, we already have codebug.eu,

but ultimately decided not to shift our

domain over to that domain as a quick

fallback due to technical consequences

that are tied to the domain name, e.g.

multi-domain support in Forgeo, SEO,

two-factor authentication,

and requiring updating all Git remotes,

etc.

So this is kind of one of these

scary stories that we keep seeing.

We've seen stories earlier this year,

like we saw with Autistici.

They also had the same issue on a

much higher scale, I would say.

But domain registrars and also just the

TLD registrars as well,

they also have quite a lot of control.

So when you do have a domain,

it's worth it to actually kind of think

about it as...

You're basically renting it in the large

scheme of things, right?

So I guess I'll throw it back to

you, Nate.

This was definitely one topic that people

were kind of concerned about on the forum.

Do you have any thoughts?

What was your initial thoughts on this

one?

Man, I don't know.

Because it's tricky, right?

There's...

I think I've moved it to ghost.

But years ago,

I wrote a blog post where I kind

of tore apart the idea of trust no

one.

Because at the end of the day,

you're always trusting someone, right?

And to put it in a real life

context, it's like most jobs,

here in the US at least,

you get paid after the job.

So if I...

I don't know why I would,

but if I quit Privacy Guides and I

go get a normal nine to five job,

they're not gonna hand me a paycheck and

then go, all right,

here's your first two weeks,

see you on Monday.

I have to go for two weeks and

then they hand me a paycheck, right?

And same thing with the building.

Like you go in the building,

you trust that it's been properly built,

properly inspected.

It's not gonna suddenly collapse on you,

which unfortunately does happen sometimes

and I'm not even being flippant.

So like you're always trusting someone

somewhere.

So this idea of just like never trust

anyone

what are you going to do?

Set up your own domain registrar,

set up your own TLD registrar.

I mean, sure.

Technically you can, right?

Like they aren't magical people from

another realm,

the people who did this stuff,

but it's a lot of work and there's

a whole process to it.

And, you know, it's not like you just,

it's not like you just put some lines

of code.

It's not like an onion service where you

just put some lines of code out there

and you're like, all right, this is mine.

Like it's more complicated than that.

So, um, I mean,

onion domains are definitely one thing

that came to mind.

Like if you can run an onion mirror

of your site, um,

that is incredibly hard to take down.

At least the domain itself.

Nobody's going to take the domain itself

down.

They might take the VPS down, but yeah,

even then, an onion domain is like, okay,

that's cool,

but

it's only a handful of people,

depending on your audience,

only a handful of people might know how

to find that.

And yeah, I mean,

I think there are reasons for like an

alternate domain I thought was a really

cool idea,

but I totally get the reason why,

you know, it's like, oh,

half of the people's two FA won't work,

like especially YubiKeys and stuff like

that because they're linked to the domain

name.

So yeah, it's, I mean, man,

it's one of those things where I don't

know if I have a good clean answer

and it's probably...

case by case kind of thing but it's

also one of those things that i think

if you run a project is really important

to think about like what would happen if

this happened and try your best to like

plan for it now and have those plans

in place you know i mean i think

that's the best i got

Yeah,

I think it is one of those things

where it's kind of unfortunate that a lot

of these platforms,

I don't think they realize the scale that

some people are operating at, right?

Like Codebug,

they're not the biggest company ever,

right?

They don't have the largest amount of

resources,

but there's a lot of people that rely

on them for hosting code.

And if they just suddenly disappear,

even for hours at a time,

like that can really throw like a wrench

in things, right?

We've seen that also with GitHub as well.

They've been having outages and that's

been causing issues too.

So it's tricky, especially when,

like you said,

there's so much tied to that domain

itself.

I think it is kind of tricky.

But you did touch on a little bit

like with onion domains.

I guess it's not really a domain.

It's a hidden address, I guess.

But it's really-

yeah yeah it's it's a way to access

the website at least um so that is

pretty cool because it protects like both

ends of the of the actual host right

like it it's protecting the person hosting

the website and it's protecting the person

accessing the website as well so

you know,

you can't actually trace back where the

website's being hosted,

which is one thing that's, it's very cool.

And that is one way that a lot

of these, you know,

services get shut down because of false

reports.

You know,

you can send that to any sort of,

you know,

domain registrar or VPS host.

And, you know,

it's in a lot of cases,

they're just using an automated system.

They're going to just take down your

account first without having to inspect

things too closely.

Right.

Which,

which sounds like what happened here.

Right.

They got a,

they got a report that were like,

oh yeah, this looks malicious.

We're going to take down the entire

domain,

but they probably didn't quite realize

that this was a code hosting service that

literally has free accounts for people

that can, um, basically, you know,

anyone can upload stuff.

So, you know,

there's obviously going to be abuse

happening.

But the fact that their domain registrar

wasn't like kind of notified that that

would possibly be something that could

happen and that they weren't kind of ready

for receiving those reports is a little

concerning.

Yeah,

I think that's the part that kind of

frustrates me is like,

why did whoever saw this malicious repo,

why did they go straight to the domain

registrar?

I mean, like,

did they not take the time to poke

around Codeburg and see?

Because I can understand if they poked

around Codeburg and it was like, oh,

this looks abandoned.

This website looks abandoned.

Probably, yeah.

won't uh you know they won't respond but

codeberg is very active if you poke around

for five minutes you'll see it's a very

well-maintained website so i don't

understand why they skipped that and just

went straight to like the the um the

registrar that's that's really confusing

to me too so i don't know

Strange stuff.

And I wonder, I don't know.

I think, I mean,

it's a lot of speculation right now,

right?

Like we don't know what was going on.

We don't know if this was like a,

a coordinated,

like if they got a ton of complaints

or I think they said they only got

like two complaints or something,

but yeah, we don't,

we don't know if this was somebody acting

maliciously or somebody just not really

paying attention to what they were doing,

but.

Who knows?

I did have one thought here to end

on if you're ready to move on to

the next story,

or did you have any final thoughts to

add?

Oh, no, definitely.

Just what were you going to add?

Yeah,

I wanted to throw it over to the

community.

I think a little thought experiment is

like,

what FOSS project would hurt you the most

if they got taken down like this?

And maybe go donate to them.

It's that time of year to like,

everybody's trying to raise donations and

tax-free charity and stuff.

And maybe Codeburg too.

If you're like,

I already donate or I can't think of

anybody,

like Codeburg could probably use the help

right now.

So yeah, just, I don't know,

something to think about.

Definitely.

Somebody said,

just visited r slash mathematics on Reddit

and every single post is a meme about

anthropic said proof.

Oh boy.

I probably wouldn't understand any of

them.

Right.

All right.

Well, I guess on that note,

we'll go ahead and move into our next

story about Apple.

This should be a pretty quick one,

but this is, in my opinion,

this is good news.

This is an update.

So y'all may remember,

it was actually last year.

It feels like it was so much longer

ago.

The UK quietly ordered Apple to build a

backdoor into advanced data protection.

I'm going to go ahead and read this

article because I actually really like the

way they covered it,

including all of their personal

commentary.

So the Investigatory Powers Tribunal,

which is essentially a British court that

deals with complaints about state

surveillance,

has ruled that Apple is allowed to reveal

a secret order it received from the UK

government.

The story centers on Apple's introduction

of the Advanced Data Protection or ADP

privacy feature back in twenty twenty two.

This extended end to end encryption to

almost all of your iCloud data.

Not all of it,

but almost all of it,

meaning that even Apple has no access and

therefore cannot grant access to any

government agencies who come knocking on

the door.

The feature is off by default.

However,

those who want to maximize the privacy of

their iCloud account can enable it.

In twenty twenty five,

the British government ordered Apple to

create a back door to allow access by

security services and law enforcement.

Which quick note for anyone who doesn't

know,

we are opposed to back doors because there

is no such thing as a back door

that only the good guys can use.

We have literally seen real world examples

of this,

but I guess computers are hard for some

people to understand,

especially when the experts put it in such

simple terms.

Not even talking about myself there for

the record,

just multiple experts from all walks of

life say it that simply.

And for some reason they're just like,

but what if we did?

Anyways, sorry,

that's a soapbox for another time.

It would have been illegal for Apple to

reveal that it had been instructed to

compromise the privacy of customer data,

but the company found a clever way to

effectively communicate this without

breaking the law.

Apple announced that it was withdrawing

ADP from the UK without explaining its

reason.

And here's the quote.

Apple can no longer offer advanced data

protection in the United Kingdom to new

users and current UK users will eventually

need to disable the security feature.

ADP protects iCloud data with end-to-end

encryption,

which means the data can only be decrypted

by the user who owns it and only

on their trusted devices.

We are gravely disappointed that the

protections provided by ADP will not be

available to our customers in the UK.

As we have said many times before,

we have never built a backdoor or master

key to any of our products or services

and never will."

I like their little,

this is from the article.

They said,

tell me you've been ordered to create a

backdoor without telling me you've been

ordered to create a backdoor.

So the actual ruling from the home office

said that, or excuse me,

the actual ruling from the tribunal says

the home office has not established that

it would be damaging to national security

to reveal that Apple had received a

technical capability notice.

And the ruling means that much of Apple

and the nonprofit's legal challenge can

now take place in open court.

The nonprofits they referenced there,

by the way,

is just like a bunch of organizations are

all getting together to push back on this.

One of the great ironies,

this is again the article, which is,

like I said,

I love the way they put this.

One of the great ironies is that most

people had never heard of ADP until the

government effectively made it headline

news in the tech press three years after

it launched,

a classic example of the Streisand effect.

To be clear,

the actual requirement for a backdoor

remains in place,

but this can now be challenged in open

court.

So turning it over to you, Jordan,

if the backdoor order is still in place,

why are we excited about this?

Why do we think this is a win?

I mean,

I think the big thing with this is

that it kind of shows what's going on

behind the scenes, right?

Like what the UK government is trying to

do.

I think one thing that I saw in

this article that you didn't mention,

I guess, was I think, you know,

this is one of these things where I

talk to people and I'm like,

Yeah, I use ADP with Apple iCloud,

you know, it encrypts everything.

And people don't really know what it is.

But now that this has happened,

literally everybody knows about this

feature and is kind of mad about it,

right?

So...

Now we know that there was the UK

government has basically issued, you know,

an order to Apple to allow access to

people's encrypted data,

which we probably wouldn't have maybe

found out if this didn't all kind of

go out in court.

Right.

So that's cool.

But also, you know,

I think it's definitely having one of

these.

I think nine to five said it's a

classic example of the Streisand effect.

you're basically saying this is a terrible

feature.

It's allowing criminals and people to

protect their privacy.

It's awful.

And then everyone's kind of, you know,

now knows that this feature exists and is

realizing this is actually quite a good

thing that people should have access to.

So...

I think this kind of was a fail

on all fronts for the UK government,

you know,

trying to ban this and then trying to

order Apple to create a backdoor basically

has kind of pushed it to the forefront

for everybody.

And,

and now we know that they were trying

to access people's encrypted data and

yeah, I don't know.

I don't know if you have something

specific that you wanted to add as well.

Um, no, I just,

just real quick for anyone who doesn't

know,

cause I'm pretty sure this predates me

too, but, uh,

the Streisand effect for anyone who

doesn't know where that comes from is, uh,

this is a true story.

Apparently way back in the day,

Barbara Streisand bought a house and, uh,

I want to say this is like eighties,

nineties, um, maybe even earlier,

but this was like pre internet and, uh,

or at least pre nowadays she bought a

house.

And, um, I think like a, a,

a tabloid took a photo of her house.

And so she sued them to not publish

the photo,

but it had already been published.

And so it turned into one of those

things where it's like everybody was like,

oh, what photo?

You know, it like piques the curiosity.

It's like, well,

now I want to see what photo.

What's wrong with it?

Why do you want to take it now?

And there was nothing wrong with it.

If I remember correctly,

she just wanted her privacy, which,

you know.

Regardless of who it is, we support that.

But, you know,

it turned it into a thing where people

who normally wouldn't have cared like, oh,

it's a photo of a celebrity's house.

Who cares?

Now, all of a sudden,

everybody wanted to see it.

Like,

I'm sure you guys have seen this in

your own lives.

Like the most recent one that I remember,

which I'm sure is not the most recent,

but I'm not super plugged into pop

culture, was Beyonce at the Super Bowl.

Apparently,

somebody snapped a picture of her at a

particular moment when she was dancing.

It was just a very unflattering look.

And, uh, everybody like, you know,

she's like, oh,

please don't share it around.

And of course everybody did because that's

how the internet works.

Um,

dag overhaul said maybe she was topless.

I don't know.

That was before my time.

Um, but either way, again,

it turned into one of those things that

like,

if she had said nothing and done nothing,

it would have dropped out of the news

cycle in ten minutes.

And because she made a big deal out

of it,

it just went viral.

And so that's what the Streisand effect

refers to, which is, yeah,

like you're saying, I mean,

I haven't had a lot of conversations about

ADP here in the US,

but I would not at all be surprised

if this is the first time people are

hearing about it and they're like,

what the hell is ADP?

Oh, really?

Better security.

Hold on.

How do I turn that on?

Is that here?

Like, wouldn't surprise me at all.

So, yeah.

Yeah,

especially because Apple has gone to

pretty big lengths to make sure that that

feature is actually very accessible for

people.

And, you know,

it allows for recovery via legacy contacts

and stuff like that.

So, you know, you don't really need to,

even if you forget your password,

you can still get back into the encrypted

data even.

So I think Apple has done a good

thing by trying to raise the bar for

encryption in cloud services.

And I think this is one of these

things where everyone else should be

taking notes.

If a government is trying to challenge you

and trying to get you to basically

introduce some sort of backdoor to disable

this feature,

then clearly it's something that should be

there by default.

it shouldn't be an option it should just

be how the service operates in the first

place and then you know they can't be

asked to turn it off so you know

if it's if it's literally baked into the

actual service it it kind of stops this

sort of thing so i wish apple would

actually enable this by default and it

would become like the default way that

data is encrypted in icloud they've made

good like moves to allow more and more

data to be encrypted in icloud but i

think it could be

go to a point where things are,

everything is by default.

And then, you know,

maybe they would have more of a challenge

to basically challenge this because this

entire thing is happening in open court.

And as far as I know, it's,

they're still challenging it, right?

So we're not seeing this go fully through

yet,

but it's just one of these cases where

we're going to see who's going to win.

And I don't think it's going to be

the UK.

I just have a feeling.

I have a feeling Apple is going to

win on this one.

every single time we've seen a case like

this,

like even we did a video about it,

like the iPhone that they wanted to

introduce, you know,

software backdoors into the device and

stuff in the US.

And, you know,

it ended up being kind of drawn out

and there was a lot of opposition to

it in the end.

So I think this sort of thing is

not a good look for the UK government

as well,

because

you know,

it makes them look like they just want

to access a bunch of people's information

for no reason and invade people's privacy,

which it's already a massive problem in

the UK.

Um,

I just don't see this going well for

them.

Um, and I hope that Apple does,

does win against it.

So yeah, for sure.

Um,

Yeah, I was going to say it's... Well,

first of all, sorry,

my brain circled back to this.

Apparently, no,

Barbra Streisand was not topless.

It was just a photo of her house,

and she didn't like that her name was

attached to it.

And I was wrong.

It was in two years ago.

And according to Wikipedia,

it was something like...

The image had only been downloaded six

times prior to Streisand's lawsuit,

two of them being her attorneys.

And then after the case led to public

awareness,

more than four hundred twenty thousand

people visited the website over the

following month.

So, yeah.

But no, it's it's very.

It's it's very like this,

this I'm with you,

like a lot of the time we see

the government kind of.

pull back on these cases.

Like they know that this is not a

good look for them and they don't really

have a lot of evidence and they're really

not eager to put all that evidence into

court paperwork.

Um, so yeah, uh,

real quick on the topic of ADP,

do you, do we recommend ADP or, um,

That is an extremely good question,

actually.

As far as I'm aware, no.

But in the inside, basically,

we have different sections on the website.

It's one of these sections that I'm less

familiar with, actually.

But there's an operating system and a

guide section for different operating

systems on our website.

but it's in the knowledge base in the

iOS overview,

we do recommend enabling advanced data

protection in that specific guide.

But again,

we don't recommend iCloud per se.

So just to make it clear,

we don't recommend iCloud,

but on our website,

if you go to the iOS overview in

the knowledge base,

we do recommend enabling advanced data

protection.

If you have to use an iPhone,

we do recommend that you enable it.

So yes,

it's not as robust as what we recommend

in our cloud services section.

And if you're using iCloud,

you should a hundred percent be using

advanced data protection.

in our opinion.

It's just better in every way and it

offers better protection for all your data

that you store there.

So make sure to check that out.

There was some comments that were in the

privacy guides supporters signal chat.

And there was some person there who said,

I'm sure a company as big as Apple

can figure out how to work out all

the kinks.

Exactly.

I think when it comes to these massive

corporations,

they really have no excuse not to be

able to implement things correctly and

actually make security be the default.

And Apple has been pretty good with this

sort of thing.

But again, it's one of these cases where

They've done good,

but they could do better.

So, you know,

just because they've done good doesn't

mean that we let them off the hook.

Like they could definitely improve it and

make things better.

But it's definitely one of those areas

that we do recommend you do that.

But obviously we don't recommend iCloud

Drive or anything like that.

Yeah, I will say to Apple's defense,

I kind of see where they're coming from

in the sense that like, this is actually,

I remember now,

this is what I was going to say

a second ago, is the whole like,

it's not enabled by default because they

can't reset your password.

They can't recover your data.

And I do sympathize with them because

like,

Yeah, I'm going to call her out.

She doesn't watch this.

I apologize.

My mother-in-law, so my wife's mom,

last week texted us, or earlier this week,

texted us and was like, hey,

I got an email that says that somebody

logged into my Apple ID or whatever,

and I'm not sure if it's legit.

And from the way she was describing it,

we couldn't tell either without looking at

it.

It sounded like, well, it might be legit.

I don't know.

And so we were trying to ask her,

well, who's it from?

And she's like, I don't know.

and it's like okay well what does it

say and she like read it and it

sounded pretty legit and it's like well

can you take a screenshot and send it

to us we had to wait like three

days for her her other kid to come

over and like take the screenshot for her

and send it to us and the minute

we laid eyes on it it's like oh

yeah no this is a phishing email like

you can tell the from is weird and

the the title the formatting on the title

has like random bold letters for some

reason like this is definitely phishing

But, you know, it's...

And I'm not trying to pick on her.

I'm not trying to call her stupid.

But, like,

those are the kind of people that they're

dealing with that it's like,

I don't know my password.

Like, she doesn't know her Apple password.

She hasn't logged in in years.

She just goes to the store,

buys a new phone,

and they transfer everything over.

And it's like, if she ever lost,

she'd be completely locked out.

And I don't think that's a good thing

for the record.

I've written blog posts in the past about

how I think that...

there's a certain baseline level of tech

literacy that I think should come up in

general.

Like I'm not saying everybody needs to

learn how to code and self host,

but like maybe people should know what a

firewall is, what an operating system is,

what a web browser is.

Yes.

These are actual things I've heard people

ask me like, what is that?

But I understand where Apple's coming

from.

That is like,

if we enabled this by default,

it would just like,

we would piss off everyone,

even though it's their fault.

Not, not again, not trying to be rude,

but even though Apple didn't do anything

wrong,

they were trying to make it more safe.

But yeah,

Yeah, I see where they're coming from.

I know some people are going to say,

like, that's not the reason.

That's just an excuse.

But like that person in the chat said,

maybe there is a way for Apple to

kind of like pass keys,

to do it in a way where it

is more secure,

but it's still user-friendly.

I don't know.

But...

I certainly see that side of the argument.

Somebody said, are there any... Oh, sorry.

I was just going to say real quick,

somebody had a question that,

are there any risks to ADP?

I mean, yeah,

it's not everything is encrypted.

So make sure you read the page about

what is and isn't encrypted.

I think emails and calendar, I think,

are not encrypted.

And like we've been saying,

if you forget the password,

you're locked out.

So be really careful with that.

Yeah, definitely.

I do want to quickly mention though,

Sod This All, they just gave us, uh,

uh, fifty-five jewels.

I'm not sure what that means,

but thank you so much.

I'm not sure if that's, like,

a donation or if, like,

I'm not really quite sure what that means,

but thank you.

Um, cool.

Thanks for that.

Really appreciate it.

Thanks for your support.

Yeah,

all these websites are always rolling out

new features.

And I'm like,

I don't know what these are.

I noticed it said Vice City Heart, though.

Yeah, he put it up on screen,

Vice City.

All right.

Everybody's playing GTA, I guess.

I don't know.

I have GTA V,

but I've only played like two hours of

it, to be honest.

I should give it another shot.

But anyways, I think that'll...

Well, yeah, I mean,

here we have in the show notes,

if viewers have any opinions, like,

what do you guys think is going to

happen next?

Do you think the UK government,

like I said,

do you think they're going to realize this

is not a good look?

They're going to drop the lawsuit and try

something else?

Or do you think the UK is actually

going to be like, yeah,

let's take this to court?

And do you have ADP enabled if you're

an Apple user?

So let's let us know your thoughts.

And on that note,

I think we're going to dive into site

updates now.

Yeah,

so we've got some site updates this week.

Before we dive into that often forgotten

way your data can get legally shared

around,

let's give some quick updates about what

we've been working on at Privacy Guides

this week.

Just a reminder to leave your questions

and comments in the chat and we'll get

to them in a moment.

But first,

what do we have in terms of video

updates, Nate?

Yeah.

All right.

Well, first, not quite a video update,

but we want to let you guys know

there will not be a live stream this

week.

It is Thanksgiving week here in the U.S.,

and therefore,

we're kind of expecting that most viewers

are going to be pretty busy.

I'll be honest,

I'm kind of an introverted nerd.

I'm not going to be super busy.

The family I have is actually close in

the area.

So we are getting together for

Thanksgiving,

but I'm not like flying across the country

or anything.

So I will be around on Friday,

but you know, it's just,

it's a lot of moving parts.

A lot of people are traveling and we

thought about maybe doing it like earlier

in the week, but then we thought like,

It'd be so early.

There aren't even really going to be any

stories.

But yeah,

so we figure you guys will be busy.

Have fun with your families.

Avoid Black Friday because the stores are

insane.

And we'll be back on December fourth,

I believe it is.

But as far as actual video updates,

if you guys didn't see,

we put out a video about Graphene OS.

This is kind of loosely a follow-up to

our...

I think I ranted about this before,

but when we put out our video a

couple months ago, weeks ago, whatever,

about the whole San Bernardino shooting

and the iPhone five C,

a lot of people seem to think that

we were recommending people go get an

iPhone five C or something.

And it's like, no,

this is just a historical thing that

happened.

And, but that kind of got us thinking,

it's like, well,

why don't we put out a video about

graphene?

Like, why don't, why don't we,

we haven't done one.

Why don't we put out a video about

like,

this is the phone the FBI can't hack

today.

And so, uh,

this is a pretty short video.

I think it's about

Yeah.

It says our last section is ten minutes

and thirty six seconds.

And it's well,

as you can see from the thumbnails here,

it's like, what is Graphene OS?

What are the security features?

What are the privacy features?

What are the user facing features that you

can actually see,

like scrambling the pin and stuff like

that?

We talk about some of the innovations that

they made in the privacy space,

like storage scope, secure clipboard.

We talk about how to use Graphene OS,

like how to where to get it,

stuff like that.

So, yeah.

So yeah,

it's a good video to share around,

I hope.

Obviously, I'm biased.

I helped write it and stuff.

But hopefully,

it's a good video that you guys can

share around for people who maybe don't

know what Graphene OS is.

Or if you're like me, I tell everybody,

it's like, oh, yeah,

there's this Graphene OS phone.

If you have a Pixel,

you should totally try it.

And they're like,

I don't know what that means.

And so this is a good video now

to send to people about that.

Um,

somebody said here real quick in the

comments on the topic of graphene,

they posted on mass on that.

Google is trying to convince OEMs to stop

working with them and possibly not provide

unlocked bootloader.

I, I saw that post.

Um,

that is definitely unfortunate if true.

And, uh,

I mean,

it wouldn't be outside the realm of

possibility, right?

Because Google is really cracking down

hard on the Android ecosystem and the

former openness of it,

which we will be discussing a little bit

later.

So stick around for that.

And then, yeah, as far as videos,

we have an Obtanium tutorial,

which I believe is in progress right now.

And Jordan could probably share more about

that if there's any updates.

That's what we got going on.

And I'm scripting the next video,

which I'm very excited to share with you

guys.

It's a topic that's near and dear to

my heart and something that people don't

talk about very often,

but definitely should.

And I'll just leave it at that for

now.

Sounds good.

Yeah.

I'm really excited for the Obtanium video

that we've been working on.

I think it's coming together well.

I think it's going to be really useful

for people because it's one of those

things where I was a little confused at

how it worked initially.

And I definitely did have to do a

bit of researching and stuff.

So I think it's good that that's going

to be sort of one of those videos

that we can have as like a evergreen

sort of video that we can link people

that's going to hopefully... Well, I mean,

evergreen...

It's going to update,

but I know there's definitely plans to

release Obtanium in stable,

so it's definitely possible that it might

change slightly when it's fully released,

but it seems like it's getting close to

stable at this point.

I guess in terms of site updates this

week,

we did have a single update on GitHub.

I had a look at that and I

approved it as well as Fria.

But basically it was an update on our

AI chat page,

which basically one of the pieces of

software that we recommend,

which is called Olamer,

which is basically an offline large

language model client where you can attach

different models to it.

It had experimental support for Meta's

basically llama vision capabilities,

which basically means, you know,

generative image creation.

And that's now not experimental.

It's now a feature that exists in Ollama

officially.

So yeah,

it can process images alongside text.

It allows it to basically,

I believe the way that I understand it

is it's a,

basically it's like a instruction set that

allows it to

visually recognize things um and answer

general questions about images stuff like

that so um as far as i'm aware

it doesn't that's not actually a

generation feature it's just like it's

gonna basically like take an image

visually recognize what it is and you know

give you sort of an output based on

that.

So definitely an interesting feature

that's part of Ollama,

but it was a feature that isn't

experimental.

It's now officially added.

So we did have to make an update

there on the website.

And as usual,

there is plenty of news briefs this week,

which Freya has been working on.

One of them specifically was Humble Bundle

redesign removes two factor authentication

and other important account security

features.

Yeah, so that's a bit yikes.

Bitwarden adds native Parsky support for

Windows and macOS,

and there were a couple more that you

can see on screen,

but those were some of the most

interesting ones.

So definitely keep an eye on

privacyguides.org slash news if you want

to keep up to date with all sorts

of privacy and security news that are

going on.

But with that being said,

all of this is made possible by our

supporters.

You can sign up for a membership or

donate at privacyguides.org or even pick

up some swag at shop.privacyguides.org.

Privacy Guides is a nonprofit which

researches and shares privacy-related

information and facilitates a community on

our forum and matrix, and also Fluxer now,

where people can ask questions and get

advice about staying private online and

preserving their digital rights.

Now let's give a quick update.

on google's android app developer

verification program remember to leave

your questions in the chat and we'll get

to them in between stories i did see

a question right here and we are in

between stories so i guess i'll throw it

to you nate there was a question in

the chat did you guys have any experience

using graphene os with mysudo um do you

have any experience with that

Yeah,

I use my pseudo just because I can't...

I know there's JMP chat and stuff,

but I haven't quite figured out how to

compartmentalize,

how to recreate that compartmentalization

in JMP chat in a cost-effective way.

So for now, I'm still on my pseudo.

I haven't had any difficulty with it on

honestly any of the OSs I've tested.

I've used it on iOS.

I've used it on Calix.

I've used it on Graphene.

I will say that...

Voice over IP in general,

in my experience,

tends to be very hit or miss.

So there are times that,

and this is across the board.

Again, this is on stock Android.

This is on iOS.

This is on every OS.

Sometimes it just doesn't ring and goes

straight to voicemail.

And sometimes it works perfectly.

And sometimes it's,

what's the word I'm looking for?

Um,

sometimes it's user error and sometimes it

just seems to happen for no discernible

reason.

So, uh, voiceover IP is,

is always going to be treated as a

second class citizen on mobile devices,

I think.

Um, but yeah, I,

I haven't had any difficulty.

Now I will say the thing is I

signed up years and years ago before I

started switching phones so much.

So I do know that a lot of

people have said you can't sign up with

a new account on Graphene.

You have to have an existing account and

import it.

So in that sense,

I've never had any trouble.

But yeah,

if you're thinking like I'm going to start

totally fresh,

I'm going to start with a brand new

account, brand new everything, that yeah,

you'll probably have some difficulty.

Yeah,

I think that is one of those issues

where I have seen that MySudo has said,

you know,

there's issues with MySudo working

correctly on GrapheneOS.

There's, like,

workarounds to get it to work properly.

I think the main issue that people were

having was creating the initial account

was the problem.

Basically,

if you create the account on a GrapheneOS

device, it doesn't work properly.

So...

I'm not really sure about all the details,

but hopefully that's something that

they've worked out.

It has been a while since I've tested

it.

Sorry,

I was following up real quick on a

question here.

Somebody said, this one here,

have you ever tried downloading Tudor

through Obtanium?

I tried to download it,

the correct Tudor mail app,

didn't successfully download, didn't care,

let the incomplete download sit.

A few days later,

it downloaded into the Tudor drive app.

And yes, yes, yes, yes, yes, yes.

Real quick,

I'm gonna throw this up on screen.

This will be quick, I promise.

Notice over here for, for video viewers,

how there's in the title, iOS desktop,

Android drive, drive, calendar, calendar,

um,

I didn't realize Drive was already

public-public like that.

Anyways,

just remember that when the Obtanium video

comes out.

I learned a lot researching for that

video.

My Obtanium experience is so much better

now, having watched that video.

And I think yours will be too.

Because, yeah, once you watch the video,

you're going to see and be like,

oh my god.

It's basically...

Tudor does it too.

A lot of companies will publish all their

stuff in one repo instead of like,

this is the repo for the iOS app

and this is the repo for the desktop

app.

And you have to tell Obtanium how to

filter it out.

So yeah,

I'll leave that as a teaser for the

Obtanium video because yeah,

that one got me too.

It's super annoying.

Yeah,

that's definitely one issue that I've run

into.

And, you know,

I think it's definitely going to be

answered by the video.

So stay tuned for that.

It's going to be a good one,

I think.

But with that being said,

I guess we can dive into this next

article here.

Google will launch Android app

verification requirement globally in

January,

the apps you download from the Play Store

all come from verified developers and

Google's new requirement expands that

requirement to apps that

from third-party sources.

Once developer verification is live in

your region,

you won't be able to sideload apps unless

the developer has registered with Google,

which is framed as a security measure.

Verification requires providing government

identification and paying a

September Google launched verification in

Brazil Indonesia Singapore and Thailand

apparently nothing exploded so the company

is now ready to expand it previously said

verification would go global in twenty

twenty seven and it's not wasting any time

with the January start it says that

verification will reach all devices within

several months so far Google is getting

what it wanted with this initiative with

millions of non-play apps already

registered

The company says that accounts for more

than ninety nine percent of global Android

app installs.

The Verifier system service has already

been rolled out to Google certified

devices running Android eight.

which accounts for just about every

Android device in the world outside of

China and Russia.

Google has also partnered with the biggest

third-party app stores to enforce

verification, Galaxy Store, Honor, Oppo,

Xiaomi, Transition, and Vivo.

hobbyists will be able to register free

accounts to distribute apps to a small

group.

Google initially planned to limit this to

twenty five total installs,

and that has been increased to fifty

installs.

Google also relented and created an opt

out system for users who don't want their

installations limited.

This so-called advanced flow will let you

install whatever you want,

regardless of verification status.

But it's not a simple toggle.

The option will be buried and there will

be plenty of scary warnings about the

risks.

You'll also have to wait twenty four hours

to fully activate the feature.

This setting is already live,

so you can tell your phone to ignore

verification right now,

but

Also, just to be clear,

this doesn't exist on Graphene OS.

Even if Google has managed to make

verification a little more warm and

cuddly,

it still gives the company a lot more

control.

Developers in sanctioned nations won't be

able to verify their identities,

locking them out of app distribution.

Sideloading an app may also require a

Google server connection.

Only popular app IDs will be cached on

devices for verification purposes.

For others,

your phone will have to check with Google

before installing.

These will be edge cases, certainly,

but still very annoying ones.

So this is interesting as well.

There was some other documentation from

Google which suggests they expect

verification to be fully online by March

first, twenty twenty seven.

So I guess to throw this back to

you, Nate,

like there's an opt out feature.

It exists like we can still install any

app that we want.

But why is this still bad?

Why is this still an issue?

Real quick,

I just got to say something that popped

into my head while you were reading

towards the end there.

It says popular apps will be cached on

device,

which obviously is going to include things

like TikTok and Facebook and Instagram.

I just know Meta is going to find

a way to abuse that.

I don't know how.

I don't even know how it's technically

possible.

They will find a way.

Anyways, okay.

In answer to your question, yeah,

because I know a lot of people might

think that, right?

Like, okay, well, there's an opt-out.

It's not great, but at least it's there.

But the thing is,

it's going to make it even harder for

people who use third-party apps.

Like, my wife is on stock Android.

I have been unable to convince her to

try out graphing so far.

And she actually does use F-Droid.

She gets a few of her apps from

there.

And...

I actually need to go and tinker with

her phone and make sure this thing is

turned off on her phone because now like,

it's not as simple.

It's already hard enough.

I'm sure a lot of us know it's

already hard enough to get somebody to

like, even just that,

like try out F droid,

try out a Crescent,

try out other app stores.

It's already hard enough to do that.

And now they're making it that much

harder.

It's making privacy less accessible

because,

um you know stores like f droid have

historically said they're like we refuse

to verify all our developers because

that's antithetical to our mission and

we're not gonna like verify ourselves and

then act as a proxy because that creates

a security risk by like it's something

about forcing them to like possess the

keys or something like that so it's like

what do you do now you have to

add an extra roadblock and at that point

sure you can make the argument like well

then just go ahead and switch over to

graphene completely and it's like again

that's that's already a hard enough battle

So yeah,

it's just making privacy less and less,

you know,

it's the more roadblocks they put up,

the harder it's going to be for people

to use it.

And yeah, I mean,

I didn't even touch on that,

but DAG nailed it too.

What about the developers?

You now basically have to dox themselves

just to publish an app.

I think Google did say that they're not

necessarily going to publish that

information publicly.

I could be remembering wrong.

It's, I mean,

it's definitely not good for developers

either.

It's bad across the board.

It's bad for everybody.

Yeah,

I think there's one thing that we do

recommend is, you know,

to get people more on board with this

because there's definitely people that

just download everything from the Google

Play Store.

Like they're not aware that this is an

issue.

They're not aware that this is something

that people should have access to.

It's kind of been an ongoing campaign and

we've kind of just been

sitting here watching the countdown

happen.

A lot of websites have been popping this

little counter up on the top of the

website as well.

I think I noticed that was on your

website actually, Nate.

And there's a lot of different places

where this has been shared,

but it's one thing that you can share

with people to kind of keep them up

to date on what is happening,

why this is an issue.

It basically details everything that you

need on this website.

So I'd highly recommend checking out

keepandroidopen.org.

It's definitely a good one to kind of

like explain the issue to someone who's

maybe less technical or whatnot.

It's one of those things that

I've tried to convince people, like,

when they said that they were going to

stop you from sideloading,

I think people were much more opposed to

it.

But now they've kind of backed down

slightly on it, where it's still possible,

but it's, like,

much more complicated for it to actually

work.

So, again, though,

the actual thing is that every Android app

developer must register with...

with Google, which is the issue.

The side loading part is also kind of

concerning,

but it's the issue with the developers

being forced to register with Google.

That's going to give Google a lot of

control over what apps you're allowed to

install on your device,

which shouldn't be the case.

Hopefully that explains somewhat of what

we're trying to say here.

Google frequently has restrictions on what

they allow people to upload.

That's why there's plenty of apps that

exist outside of the Google Play Store

that break Google Play's terms of service.

Whether they're right about those apps

being listed or not is up for

interpretation.

There's plenty of apps that are...

offering services that are in competition

to Google that they don't like.

Plenty of YouTube music clients or things

like that that Google doesn't want to

exist on there.

So we shouldn't be giving Google access to

what apps we can install on our devices.

It's up to us.

We should be able to use whatever we

want, whenever we want,

and install whatever software we want on

our devices.

So

Definitely check out that website.

And if you're a developer,

please don't sign up for this.

Don't give Google your information.

That's one of the ways that we can

resist this.

But it does sound like a lot of

developers are caving, unfortunately.

Yeah.

I kind of made a face because my

website's actually down.

I was going to go show my website

and just how that little banner is up

at the top, like you said.

And as soon as I typed it in,

I'm like, oh, that's right.

It's been down all day.

Actually, yeah,

the only final thought I had, really,

because I don't have anything else to add,

is Brennan West said,

we need a third contender in the ring

that cares about privacy and security.

I mean,

I know people always talk about Linux

phones,

and I personally don't think they're quite

up to par in terms of security,

at least,

when compared to something like Android.

But I've been saying for years that I

love the idea of a Linux phone.

I've just never found one that I thought

was actually usable in day-to-day.

Like, a lot of them...

they're basically a Linux desktop and a

phone and it's like, okay, but I can't,

I can't download signal.

I can't download my pseudo.

I can't, you know,

hardly get anything on them.

So, um,

I just wanted to throw that one over

to the audience.

Like, what do you guys think about,

are there any Linux operating systems,

mobile operating systems that you think

are actually like, no, I bet you,

you probably could use this one day to

day and average person.

I'm thinking something like UB ports where

it's got like, um,

not inbox inbox was deprecated, I think,

but something else, uh,

like wage right or something.

Um,

But it's got some kind of like Android

emulator built in.

So unfortunately,

I've never been able to get UV ports

running reliably.

But the idea is you're still able to

emulate Android and download those Android

apps that you need.

So I don't know if you guys have

any Linux phones that you think are

actually like a viable contender.

I'd be interested in checking it out for

sure.

yeah it's definitely one operating system

that i've seen for linux phones is um

it used to be called post market os

but it's now called nura um and that

does allow you to install android apps and

it's through wageroid actually so it

doesn't use um it doesn't use i think

it's called and box i believe before but

wager yeah that's the deprecated one i

think

Yeah, yeah.

So that is one way that you can

use Android apps.

Again, though,

it's one of these things where every time

I've seen people talk about Linux phones,

you know,

it just falls down in a lot of

ways.

Security, it's definitely behind.

Privacy,

I would say it's probably perfectly fine

from a privacy perspective.

But from a security perspective and from a

usability perspective,

you're just not going to come close to

what Graphing OS offers.

And...

That's kind of the main problem when it

comes to these sort of devices.

I think we've also... Like Nate mentioned,

there was a comment earlier about...

Let me see.

There was a comment that was talking about

Graphene OS being cut off from OEM

applications.

They posted on Mastodon that Google is

trying to convince OEMs to stop working

with Graphene OS.

So, you know,

it's one of those things where there's a

lot of people that have competing

interests for things, right?

And it's tricky when basically Google

controls the hardware platform a lot.

also the software platform they control

basically both so if you don't have

support from from google then it kind of

it does screw you in a lot of

ways so it's good with with linux phones

because there are so many independent

sellers of the actual hardware and there's

so many different distros of linux

operating systems that you can install on

them but again it's like it just hasn't

reached that point where it's actually i

could never recommend this to my mother i

could never recommend this to a friend

like this would just not work this just

would not be

Something that I could say is something

that is actually usable for the average

person at this point.

It's funny you mentioned post-market.

I have a Pine phone that every six

months or so, I'm like, man,

I should boot this thing up and tinker

with it and see how far it's come.

And I always get busy and I stop.

But yeah, it's like,

I basically need to figure out how to

factory reset it or something.

But it's...

Yeah, I want to like it.

I really do.

But last time I checked,

the battery could not go through a full

day just sitting on my desk,

not even in use,

just sitting on my desk.

The battery couldn't go through a full

day.

Again, didn't come with signal.

I don't know.

I want to like it, man.

I really do.

I think it'd be cool to use a

Linux phone.

I trust myself enough with the security,

but I digress.

Yeah,

I think it's one of those things where...

There are a lot of different sellers that

are making these Linux phones.

I believe there's one in Europe.

Oh, it's not coming to mind.

Sailfish?

Is it Sailfish?

Maybe it's... Mirena?

Because Sailfish is the OS.

I think Mirena is the one that sells

the actual preloaded phones,

but I could be wrong.

You might be right.

It might be Sailfish OS and then it's

Marina that sells them or something like

that.

But there's definitely different options.

We would be open to testing that sort

of thing.

But again,

it's not something that we could ever

recommend just because of the security

just doesn't compare to what the other

operating systems have.

So that's kind of the issue with that.

I definitely think Sailfish OS definitely

looks...

quite promising compared to like Neura and

Post Market OS.

I think it's Jola.

Yeah, the Jola phone.

I think that was the one.

Yeah.

Yeah.

I think you're right.

Yep.

I'm on Sailfish's website.

Yeah, you're right.

Okay.

Yeah.

Marina does EOS.

My bad.

Yeah.

I think Marina also does like Linux phones

a little bit too.

But yeah, like Jola or Yola.

Jola.

I'm not sure how you pronounce it,

but there's people that are doing-

Somebody who's finished, tell us.

yeah yeah someone someone from there but

like yeah it's it's tricky when there's

when there's all these options and they

just don't really stack up that great I

mean I'd be open to testing more of

this stuff because I know I just like

messing around with all this kind of

unique stuff like I don't think that it's

reaching a reaching a mass a critical mass

at this point but it's like it's

definitely something to keep an eye on at

least for now

I'm checking to see if Sailfish works on

the PinePhone.

Is a supported community-developed

operating system for the PinePhone and

PinePhone Pro?

Oh, well, this is an AI summary,

so take it with a grain of salt,

but allegedly the PinePhone Pro ships

Sailfish as an option for factory default.

Definitely,

definitely worth checking it out.

Maybe give it a try.

Yeah, I was going to say,

if I can get my PinePhone working,

I will happily test drive that.

I'm going to look into that a little

more later.

Oh,

I got to make some time this weekend

to get that working.

I really want to get that thing working

again.

Even if I don't use it day to

day, it's just,

it's nice to have as a, like,

I'm like you,

I like to tinker and try new things.

So I'm, uh, I'm getting,

I'm getting ideas.

Ideas are forming.

Maybe it's a video.

I don't know.

I was about to say new video.

Yeah.

Maybe it's a video.

We'll see.

We'll see.

But, um,

that is definitely something we should

definitely, um, think about at least.

Um, but yeah, um,

I'm kind of down on that.

If you had anything else.

Um, no, yeah, I guess on that note,

we'll, uh,

actually on that topic of privacy and

security and whatnot, uh,

our next forum thread is, uh, I,

I thought was an interesting question.

This person said,

what is security slash privacy theater and

how to stop it?

Um, so OP basically says, I'm a beginner.

I know some things,

but how can I tell if what I'm

doing is just theater?

Every company markets itself as secure and

private.

So are there any signs?

And, uh, I,

I thought this was interesting because to

me, this kind of struck me as, um,

A little bit crass,

but there's a famous U.S.

Supreme Court ruling from way back in the

day where they were defining pornography

and obscenity.

And some Supreme Court justice famously

said, like,

you'll know it when you see it or

something like that.

And I feel like that's kind of how

privacy and security theater are is like

it's kind of hard to put a definite

label like this is definitely it.

But it's like.

I feel like I know it when I

see it a lot of the time.

But yeah,

there were a few interesting answers.

Somebody else said their biggest red flag

is if it's source available or not,

which I do want to point out,

that's not always a guarantee.

Open source does not necessarily mean that

it's safe,

but it at least is a show of

good faith and transparency.

So it's definitely not a bad heuristic.

Uh, somebody else said, I don't think,

actually, this was a really, um,

detailed answer that I like.

They said,

I don't think there is a clear answer

because we have multiple schools of

thought about where reasonable security

stops and theater starts.

So they mentioned that apparently, um,

cryptomator and key pass XC.

So apparently when you type a password

into key pass XC on a Mac,

Mac OS has a feature that hides the

password from other apps that have

permission to read keyboard events.

So like accessibility apps, um,

crystal cryptomator doesn't do that.

And so basically an app with accessibility

permissions can read the password.

And this person says,

when I asked the Cryptomator devs about

it,

they didn't consider it a security issue.

In their opinion, they're like,

what's the point of protecting the user

from apps that already have access to

their machine?

To them, that's theater.

KeePass XE, however,

introduced this feature

And to be fair,

there were like five years of discussion

initially having the same position as

Cryptomator,

whether it's because they considered the

setup more secure or they were just tired

of people asking for it, who knows.

But there's no reason to think that the

Cryptomator devs have a better

understanding of security than the

KeePassXC devs or vice versa.

So a ton of things depend on your

views and your threat model.

Um,

and then I like what this person said

too, is like, uh, they said,

what's helpful for me is breaking down the

tool or service, what,

and what it actually does instead of the

marketing.

So for example,

the marketing might say all in one end

to end encrypted messaging platform,

secure your network traffic, et cetera.

The question I asked myself is what is

this actually doing for me?

What problem is it solving or mitigating?

And it helps me identify the value from

the first principles.

And then dig into the definitions.

Secure how?

Protect me from what?

If theater is a performance,

the way to identify it is to become

an informed consumer.

So keep asking questions and don't settle

for simple explanations.

So yeah,

I thought that was really interesting.

I think I might have a loose definition

in my head, but what...

I guess I'll throw it to you first,

Jordan.

How would you define security or privacy

theater,

and how would you try to spot it?

I guess, yeah.

The main thing that you brought up with

that other person's comment that they made

is just actually thinking about why you're

doing things.

I think what was the...

I think it's the thing that I've heard

is, you know, at airports,

they do a lot of security.

There's a lot of security at the airport.

And, you know, they find like maybe,

I don't think they've even found one

person like who was trying to sneak

something through.

Certainly not a lot.

Yeah.

It's certainly not a lot.

And there's a lot of, you know,

there's maybe a little bit to say about,

oh, it looks scary.

So, you know,

it kind of makes people not want to,

you know, break through that security.

So, you know,

I think when we look into, like,

protections that we're thinking about

choosing, I think it's important, like,

to think about exactly what it's actually

protecting.

If there's actually...

any sort of technical backing behind what

you're choosing to do and what that's

actually going to do for you.

So I don't know.

I don't really, I think there's,

there's definitely some value in having

some privacy theater and security theater.

Like, you know, I've heard people say,

I don't know,

I guess this is kind of transcending a

little bit into the real world a bit,

but you know, I've seen people say like,

I just put up security cameras,

they're dummy units, but you know,

I put them up and like,

it scares people off.

Like it's, it's, it's even that is,

you could say maybe that is like somewhat

theater because it's not actually

increasing the security of your house.

It's just,

making people less likely to want to break

into it,

which I don't know if you could do

the same thing for like a privacy or

security thing, right?

Like if you have like a Linux laptop,

if someone's going to open that,

they're probably going to be interested in

breaking into it because it looks

different.

It

I think it's one of these topics that

you kind of just have to think about

the things you're doing.

And a lot of the discussion that was

here was, like, about Keep Our Sexy and,

like, Cryptomator and stuff.

I don't really have an opinion on that

specific case, I guess.

But, yeah, I'm not sure.

Someone said that's deterrence,

not theater.

I guess, like.

Valid.

It depends.

Yeah, I guess so.

I guess, first of all,

the key pass XE versus Cryptomator thing,

I think that was their point.

It's like,

I don't think anybody's right or wrong

there.

It's just different trains of thought.

But yeah.

Yeah, it's real quick.

Somebody was on that.

The I know it when I see it

was in nineteen sixty four by a U.S.

Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart to

describe his threshold test for obscenity

in Jacobellus versus Ohio.

Somebody was on that one.

Thank you.

Thank you for looking that up.

No,

I agree with you to use real world.

I've I've I've complained about this

before.

Yeah.

Yeah, I mean,

this is basically the same question right

here from this person on YouTube.

I've talked about this before.

So I used to be a freelancer for

audio video and I've done a lot of

like conferences, concerts,

stuff like that.

And there was a specific hotel that I

would do a lot of conferences at.

And they were so strict about you have

to go check in with security.

And it's not just go check in with

security.

You have to go around the back,

go in through the back door to check

in with security.

Well, the back door is always locked.

And the back door,

there's a staircase going up.

Like literally, as soon as you come in,

it goes straight to a staircase.

And so I'm like,

it's not like I can just sit there

and bang on the door and hope somebody

walks by.

And they literally told me, they're like,

well,

just wait for someone to come out for

a smoke break or something.

And it's like, okay, first of all,

not a lot of people smoke anymore,

at least here in the US,

not that many.

It's like,

so you just want me to show up

like an hour early and just hang out

outside the back door.

And all security is going to do,

by the way,

check in with security is you write your

name, you write your time in,

and they give you one of those little,

hello, my name is stickers.

And I remember that pissed me off because

I'm like, dude, this is a hotel.

Literally anyone can walk through the

front door.

You're not going to ask them for ID.

You're not going to ask them what's in

their bag.

Like that to me is the textbook definition

of a security theater.

And giving somebody a useless job because

the security team – we all know if

something happens,

the security team is going to hide and

call nine-one-one.

No shade on them.

I would too.

But anyways, to me,

that's a textbook definition.

It's like you're not actually providing

any real security.

It's just supposed to make you feel safe.

So, I mean, yeah, me personally,

I think –

Like I get where you're going with the

camera thing.

And I think to kind of like to

take that a step further,

I think the difference between deterrence

and theater is like if you were under

the illusion that the camera was keeping

you safe, if you were like, oh,

I don't need to lock my doors anymore

because I have these dummy cameras and and

now it keeps criminals away.

all it takes is one criminal to call

your bluff and now they're in.

So, um, yeah, I think, I think, uh,

I agree with you.

Like the, the camera thing,

I would almost compare to like security

through obscurity.

Like personally,

I don't think that's a bad thing as

long as you layer it with other things.

Like, um,

I think I talked about this last week

too, like without a,

that whole SSH whole vulnerability that

was going around.

Um,

even though I don't use any Linux distros

that were affected by it,

I still kind of thought about it.

And I'm like, you know,

I think I want to move all my

ports away from .

Which is the standard SSH port,

just in case.

And, you know,

I still have like all the,

what do they call it?

The public key authentication,

like don't log in with root.

I have all of that stuff set up.

So this is just another layer.

It's not actually stopping anything.

It's just another layer.

And, you know, it's...

Yeah.

And obviously, you know this,

but like security through obscurity would

be if I didn't do any of that

other stuff.

And I'm like,

I'll just move it off port twenty two

and nobody will ever find it till they

do.

But yeah.

So I don't know.

That's that's me.

And like, how do you spot it?

I think I think that one person that

said, like, how is it helping me?

I think that's.

I guess kind of not that,

but I would ask like, again,

with the hotel security thing, it's like,

okay, well, where are the holes in this?

And obviously nothing is perfect.

If you follow it long enough, like, yeah,

everything has holes.

Everything is hackable.

But when it's so obvious,

like literally anyone can walk through the

front door with a bag and you don't

check them or ID them or anything.

I think it's safe to say your security

team is security.

But I, okay.

I probably,

probably rambled about that enough.

I think, I think one thing that's,

that is interesting,

like I was reading a bit more about

this cause I was like, yeah, maybe I,

yeah, I think, no,

maybe the example I used was, yeah,

it was more like deterrence, I guess.

I think the thing that is like big

about security theater though,

is like things that you do that

significantly restrict like, you know,

your access to a device or like things

like that, that don't have any like,

you know,

actual security increases right um i can't

really think of too many off the top

of my head um maybe that's something we

can look into a little bit more um

does anything come to mind for you though

or i mean i think maybe um i

don't know if this is so much security

theater is just crappy marketing but i

think of vpns you know how they're always

like oh and they always do it in

their marketing oh it'll make you

anonymous online and it'll protect you

from hackers and it's like

No, I mean,

a good VPN with a DNS block list

will block some trackers.

It'll block some malicious domains,

but it damn sure isn't going to make

you anonymous or hacker proof.

TSA confiscating things you can buy inside

the airport yeah I mean to their defense

I don't want to defend the TSA too

much I hate the TSA but like I

get the point is like they want to

make sure you're not bringing in something

that looks like water but is actually like

nitroglycerin or something I don't know I

don't even know what nitroglycerin looks

like but yeah that always confused me too

it's like I have to dump out my

water so I can go through the thing

to buy water there's a water fountain

right there I don't know yeah I don't

like the TSA yeah

I think one thing that I definitely,

I do remember like some organizations

pushing was like rotating passwords every

like couple of like months or like putting

silly strict requirements on passwords.

Like it has to be this many like

symbols and this many letters.

And it's like, you know,

does that really increase security or does

that just actually just make it more

annoying for people?

Yeah.

guess also just like all these kind of

goofy privacy badges that a lot of

websites have like where iso six thousand

uh certified and like all these like sort

of things it's like what does that really

mean like does that really mean anything

like it doesn't really mean anything um

it's it's kind of just it does mean

something obviously but like you know does

that really it's not really a i don't

know to the average consumer

Yeah, no, I know you know this,

but yeah,

we talked about that on our interview with

Melanie Ensign.

I asked her about that.

I'm like,

does that actually mean anything?

And she's like, not for an individual.

It means that they have certain procedures

in place, like corporate structure,

and they have these policies in place.

But for an individual, no,

that doesn't mean anything.

But yeah, you're absolutely right.

They'll still throw it up there like, oh,

look how cool we are.

But yeah, I guess I get it.

It's just marketing.

I tried to use a twelve word passphrase

the other day and it said it was

insecure because it didn't have any

numbers.

Yeah, for real.

And then, yeah, it's a...

My old company was the same way.

Every three months,

password changes everywhere.

No SSO.

We did have SSO,

but they still made us change our password

every three months.

Like, to be fair,

I actually found out that in a lot

of corporate environments,

that's not a terrible idea because then

basically, like...

for example, when I left my last company,

if the IT guy forgot to remove my

access after three months,

it's going to get revoked automatically

anyways.

But yeah, it's, it's definitely not, um,

it did backfire because it just resulted

in people, you know,

coming up with password one, password two,

password three.

So yeah,

it definitely did not work the way we,

we wanted it to.

Um,

that is probably a good example of a

digital security theater actually.

So

Um, yeah, I don't know.

I don't think I have much else on

that.

I guess I mean,

viewers have already been weighing in.

But yeah, if you have any,

how do you define it?

How do you spot it?

What do you look for?

Definitely let us know in the chat.

And I think we can move on to

the next story if you're ready.

Yeah, sounds good.

So this story is from Meredith Whitaker,

the primary person, like the, I guess,

CEO of Signal.

President.

President, sorry.

Yes.

Signal has released an article saying,

Signal is serious about protecting your

privacy.

We're restricting the latest AI agents

built into mobile operating systems from

potentially capturing and storing your

Signal data.

Last year we used screenshot blocking to

prevent Microsoft's Recall AI from taking

and storing screenshots of your signal

messages on Windows operating systems by

default.

We will now be taking similar measures to

restrict agentic systems built into iOS

and on Android versions where we can

detect an AI assistant attempting to read

your signal screen.

In order to gain access to information

about you,

these OS AI agents scan the information

that's on your screen.

In doing so, your signal data is captured,

then made available to these agentic

systems in order to allow them to answer

your questions and do your bidding.

People who want the ability to take

screenshots can disable this protection

within the Signal apps settings.

Our remedy is also incomplete.

While we are doing everything we can,

restricting screenshots does not address

other more sneaky ways AI agents could

potentially access application data,

such as retrieving content already present

on a user's device via the file system.

We want to be very clear.

It is a serious problem that signal and

application developers beyond lack robust

tools to prevent AI agents from

undermining application level privacy.

Even where we are able to detect and

block AI data access, Google, Apple,

Microsoft,

and others do not provide ways for

developers to easily restrict such AI

access.

access without making drastic compromises

to the core user experience.

This is also the reason we are currently

unable to implement these protections on

macOS.

We are also struggling with a significant

lack of documentation about how these AI

agents actually work.

Over the past few months,

we've spent considerable developer time

and energy doing forensic investigations

across Android and iOS in an attempt to

learn what is actually happening when

these AI systems access application data.

Without better documentation and clear

technical specifications,

it will be increasingly difficult for

Signal to provide robust privacy and

security to the many millions of people

who rely on us.

We continue to call on major consumer

operating system companies like Apple,

Google,

and Microsoft to provide simple technical

tools and accurate documentation that

gives developers like Signal ways to

prevent AI agents from accessing sensitive

application data.

Signal is the canary in the coal mine,

but this affects the entire ecosystem and

should galvanize anyone who cares about

these fundamental rights.

So this is kind of frustrating that a

lot of these companies are rolling out

these systems and they're seemingly not

thinking about people's privacy.

They're just like, ah, we'll do it later.

We'll get to it at some point.

So I guess to throw it back to

you, Nate, this is obviously a problem,

but does this affect everything else as

well?

This affects Signal,

but does this affect every other app that

you use as well, right?

Yeah.

Yeah,

I really liked that last line they ended

on.

Signal is the canary in the coal mine,

but this affects the entire ecosystem.

Because I already know there's going to be

people in the comments of this like, oh,

Signal's a honeypot, Signal's not private,

blah, blah, blah, whatever.

And even if you do believe that,

I don't care.

I'm not going to argue with you.

But this affects XMPP.

This affects Session.

This affects SimpleX.

This affects whatever your messenger of

choice is.

This applies to them too.

Because if you use it on a mobile

device,

and I know there's the purists out there

who are like, oh,

I'll never allow a mobile device in my

home, whatever.

Again, ninety nine percent of people,

you're the exception.

But whatever it is,

it's coming for you and it's encroaching

on you.

And it's kind of one of those like,

I mentioned this before.

There's a military history podcast I

listen to.

They call it the universal theory of F

that guy.

When two armies that hate each other hate

a third guy even more,

and they come together to fight him off.

It's the same thing.

Even if you don't like Signal,

whether it's simply like,

I don't care for it,

or you think it's a honeypot.

The overall point is they're trying to

push back on this,

and that's what they're really calling

for.

We're actually having this discussion in

the news chat right now.

Signal isn't just saying like, hey,

check us out.

We blocked this thing.

They're also saying like, by the way,

this was really hard because these things

are so baked into the operating system.

And there's so little documentation for

developers.

Like trying to make an app that opts

out of AI is so hard.

And I think we all can relate to

that.

Everywhere you go nowadays,

everything is AI.

And it's like...

if you don't want to interact with AI,

it's becoming impossible to opt out and

you're just,

you're having that freedom taken away from

you.

So yeah,

like regardless of what your messenger app

of choice is, I think it's, um,

you know, it's really important that we,

we all kind of push back on this

and recognize like, yeah,

signals got a point here on, on that.

So yeah, it affects you guys too.

Um,

I don't know.

I think other than these screenshots,

because Signal did say this is not a

complete solution.

Do you have any defenses that come to

mind that you can think of?

I mean,

I think just using devices that don't have

AI agents built into them by default is

probably one way to do it.

Again, like, that's not always an option.

I think a lot of these AI features

are optional at this point, though.

You know,

no one's forcing you to use them.

But I think it is specifically,

it is kind of a problem because...

you can know that your end is secured.

You can know that your device isn't

sending data to Claude or OpenAI or

something, right?

But if someone else on the other end

is using all these tools and routing your

messages and your personal information

into these tools,

you don't really know.

And that's why this is kind of a

problem because these sort of apps

shouldn't be able to put this data into

an AI agent because the entire purpose is

they're end-to-end encrypted.

They're not meant to send that data off

to a third party once it's received by

your device.

It breaks end-to-end encryption at that

point, right?

So try and use devices that don't have

these features

Again,

it only protects your end of the

connection.

You can't really force people to just use

Graphene OS or uninstall all these,

like disable all these AI features,

which is kind of frustrating.

But it's good that certain apps like

Signal are building them in a way that

hopefully it will not allow this by

default.

But the fact that it can be turned

off is, again,

one of these frustrating things where it's

like...

I don't think that should be,

that should not be allowed.

Like it should just not be able to

be put into an AI agent in the

first place.

It's just,

it's frustrating when companies are not

prioritizing these basic like security,

like walls that should exist.

I don't know.

That's kind of my thoughts on it.

Try and use devices that don't have it.

Try and disable it if you can.

There's not much you can really do when

it comes to other people because they're

going to be the people making those

decisions.

So, yeah.

Which I think is a good point that

goes back to,

like Kerry Parker always says,

privacy is a team sport.

It's not just... And actually,

I've been reading through it myself too,

but Privacy is Power by Carissa Bailey is

an amazing book.

And she points that out too,

how your privacy affects my privacy,

affects everybody else's privacy.

We're all in this together.

But yeah, yeah.

I just,

I do want to point out the cynical

side of me.

Yeah.

Right now,

a lot of these AI features are optional

and some of them are even opt in

how long before they're opt out and how

long before they're just not opt out.

You know, it's like, it's like,

I think I've shared this before too.

I have a smart TV and one time

just for, for, for giggles, I was like,

Oh,

let me disagree to the terms of service

and see what happens.

And it goes, well,

you can't use any of the smart features

now.

And I'm like,

Well, you're not a very useful smart TV.

Like I still want to be able to,

at least Jellyfin, my own Jellyfin server,

at least I want to be able to

access that.

Nope, you can't do anything.

You can plug in an HDMI, but yeah.

So it's a, how long before that's,

and that too,

how long before it's enabled and people

don't even realize it.

Like it, you know,

Google rolled this thing out and they're

like, oh,

we'll turn this on for your convenience.

And it's like, oh,

I didn't know I was capturing all these

sensitive conversations from my friend

that uses Signal, you know, like,

Like you were saying, like I use Signal.

I get most of my friends and family

using it.

They don't know when Google flips the

switch and turns the AI on.

And now they're like,

I didn't realize I was exposing all his

messages.

I would have turned it off if I'd

have known that, so.

Yeah, it's really unfortunate.

Yeah, I think just viewers,

if you can think of any additional

defenses.

I know somebody said carrier pigeons,

but Jonah went over that in our Messenger

video.

And carrier pigeons, they're only one way,

and you've got to ship them back,

and you've got to feed them.

And I don't know, man.

I don't know how I feel about that.

Dag Overhaul kind of said that this

feature, he would argue,

is kind of security theater because you

can just photograph the screen.

I disagree because, I mean,

nothing's perfectly unhackable, right?

And, you know, I mean...

again, it kind of goes into marketing.

Like what is signal is signal claiming

that they're going to protect you from

every single possible threat that like,

if I text my wife,

they scramble it in such a way where

only her eyes can process the light waves.

Like they're not saying that, you know,

it's obviously there's limitations to what

they can do,

but what they're trying to prevent against

is like the stuff I just said, like,

you text your,

your grandma who doesn't realize that

Samsung has turned on their garbage AI

that they should have put to rest at

ten years ago.

And now it's scooping up all your messages

and you have no idea.

And it's, it's,

it's not even just the security threat of

it.

It's,

it's all this stuff is getting sent back

for training and yeah, it's,

it's not good.

So, um, yeah.

Uh, I don't know.

You got anything else to add to that

one?

No, that's everything on my end.

All right, well, let's move into,

this is gonna be our final story.

This is a twofer because they both came

up around the same time and I was

like, oh my God,

these are kind of almost the same story

in a way, in my opinion.

So the first one comes from Reuters.

This is actually a really quick article.

It says,

US bankruptcy judge approves Spirit

Airlines data sale to Google.

So some of you guys may remember that

last year, I think it was last year,

Spirit Airlines,

which is a budget airline here in the

U.S.,

and Europeans will laugh when I say

budget,

I mean like a couple hundred dollars.

Yes, I've seen your budget airline prices,

and I'm very jealous.

But Spirit imploded.

They went bankrupt.

No, it was earlier this year,

and just for totally mysterious reasons

that nobody can figure out why,

just oil suddenly got super,

super expensive, and...

Oh, my God.

I want to be even more snarky than

that, but I'm going to resist.

Anyways,

so a federal judge in New York has

approved Google's ten million dollar

acquisition of internal business data in a

hearing on Tuesday.

Basically,

this was following concerns from labor

unions and more than one hundred and

twenty U.S.

lawmakers as part of spirits closure and

liquidation.

Google won an auction in August for

employee data from email spreadsheets and

calendars,

as well as for marketing productivity and

operations.

And Google has set up plans to use

the data for product development and

training.

Great.

A privacy ombudsman, I'll be honest,

I'm not super familiar with that word.

I know I've seen it,

but I don't really know what it means,

recommended in October that the deal be

approved only after excluding passenger

personal information from ninety seven

million spirit customers,

which to me sounds incredibly reasonable.

And yeah, I mean, obviously,

I don't think we should be selling this

data at all.

Basically Google said that they would do a

more rigorous de-identification process

than previously planned and that, uh,

employee data,

including health and medical information

would be excluded from the sale,

which again,

to me feels like a no brainer, but,

um, obviously I'm biased.

And then the other one, uh,

this actually just came up yesterday,

I think, uh,

Intuit the tax company is selling

MailChimp to Bending Spoons who seems to

just be buying up all these old companies

that um kind of trigger my nostalgia and

I don't really know what their goal is

there um so this one is it comes

from CNBC and it's mostly like uh market

stuff numbers and stuff but yeah um Intuit

said on Thursday that it has agreed to

sell MailChimp to an Italian tech

consolidator called Bending Spoons for

three point six eight billion dollars in

cash and stock uh this is set to

close in early twenty twenty seven and uh

Intuit apparently paid twelve billion

dollars back in twenty twenty one as they

were attempting to push out beyond tax and

accounting services.

And yeah, basically,

I guess they decided this just isn't

really isn't really bringing us any money

anymore.

So we're going to get rid of it.

And apparently Bending Spoons also bought

AOL, Brightcove, Eventbrite, Evernote,

Meetup, Vimeo and WeTransfer.

So.

Yeah, like I said,

there's a fun little walk down memory

lane.

But the reason I mention these stories

specifically is... To me, this is...

I mean, as we've been teasing about,

is we really, a lot of the time...

and I think we as privacy people,

this is kind of in the back of

our head,

but it's just something that doesn't get

talked about a lot.

We talk about data sharing in the context

of like trackers, analytics, data brokers,

you know, data breaches.

We talk about that kind of stuff,

but we never really,

or we don't often stop to think about

like, well, if this company gets sold,

if there's a merger,

if there's an acquisition,

if they go bankrupt.

And the thing about bankruptcy is you

don't get to, from what I understand,

you don't get to just like throw up

your hands and walk away and be like,

oh, okay, we're broke.

We tried.

Like,

You have investors that you have to pay

back or people you took loans from,

even if they're not investors, the bank,

right?

They want to get as much back possible.

So at that point,

they're going to be like, okay,

you bought a company car,

even if it's a reasonable car,

if it's a Honda Civic or something.

You can't just keep the car.

That's a company car.

You have to sell it and give us

the money.

So all the Macs you bought for the

company,

you have to sell those and give us

the money.

Um,

which I've actually heard really funny

stories about people going to ridiculous

lengths to get petty things back that it's

like, yeah, this is a,

a first generation Apple watch from like

two thousand whenever it came out.

It's worth like fifty dollars,

but cost you more in gas to come

and get it from me than it would

be to sell it.

But I digress.

Um,

So yeah, anyways, a lot of the time,

you know, when we do see these things,

hopefully we usually do,

or at least it seems to me,

we usually get some kind of notice that

like, okay,

the deal is going to close in February

and you have until then to like go

delete your account or whatever.

But also that assumes you even hear the

news.

You know,

these companies aren't exactly going out

of their way to tell you about this

and tell you your options and, you know,

make it super easy to find.

So,

Yeah,

and especially something like MailChimp in

particular contains a lot of data of

people who aren't going to be notified,

right?

Like if you,

back before I was into privacy,

my band used to use bands I was

in.

We used to use MailChimp because it's easy

and it's free and it's generous.

And so there's people that signed up for

our mailing list that would have no idea.

I mean,

I've deleted those accounts years and

years ago,

so hopefully they're not in there anymore.

But it's the same idea, right?

Like if it was still active,

if they were still there,

their data is about to get sold off

to bending spoons and they have no idea.

So yeah, yeah.

I don't know that I have many takeaways

from this.

We need better privacy laws while also

being proactive because obviously laws are

not perfect.

And I guess the only actionable takeaway I

have for viewers is reveal all of your

mailing lists and unsubscribe from the

ones you no longer get value from because

you never know if tomorrow they're going

to sell to bending spoons or somebody

else.

So do you have any thoughts on this

story, Jordan?

We've definitely had this discussion a

little bit when it comes to,

I wouldn't say like companies being sold,

but also just companies and their business

models.

Like,

I don't know if you remember a couple

of years ago, there was the issue with,

what were they called again?

The email service.

I knew that was going to come up.

Skiff?

Skiff, yeah.

I knew that was going to come up.

Companies like that, right?

We do see this a little,

like people will say, oh, you know,

Proton's never going to get sold or like

Tudor's never going to get sold or like

whatever, right?

Or SimpleX, I think,

would probably be a better example.

It does happen.

Like we've seen it happen.

So, you know,

maybe be aware of that when it comes

to a...

a organization that you're trusting your

data with,

there's always the case that it could be

part of,

like in a lot of people's privacy

policies, even they literally say like,

you know, if we're required,

we will be transferring and then it will

just list everything they're going to

transfer.

So, you know, be careful what you share.

Maybe don't share every single bit of

information with MailChimp or what was the

other one?

Spirit Airlines.

You know, be careful with those companies.

Like,

of course they need like legitimate

information, but, you know, try and be,

try and be a bit careful what you

share, because again,

like there's always the case for that to

be.

In this case, the worst possible outcome,

Google using it to train its AI,

that's pretty bad.

But it's not always going to be that

bad.

But it is one of these cases where

we've got to be careful about what

information we do share.

Because I treat basically everything that

I share with someone as public.

It's going to be public at some point.

It's going to get data breached.

It's going to be an acquisition.

There's going to be something.

So what's the risk of that being acquired?

And again, I guess in this case,

MailChimp,

it's kind of ubiquitous with people

running mailing lists.

So yeah,

definitely be careful and try and get that

deleted.

I'm not sure exactly how that works

because I wonder how that works with

organizations that use MailChimp as their

mailing list.

And then does that include,

does that mean that MailChimp can just

like

give all that data,

even though it's a specific organization's

mailing list?

Does that count?

Is that part of the sale?

I would imagine so, yeah.

Well, good luck to everyone.

Yeah, no,

the Spirit one really pisses me off

because, I don't know, I just...

We live in a capitalist society, man.

You've got to have a job,

and there's no protections for your data.

To me, the whole...

and this is just,

this comes with data too.

Like the whole like,

just don't use it argument is so

disingenuous.

Like Google, right?

If people are like, well,

just don't use Google.

First of all,

Google analytics trackers are on like,

you know, it's like, okay,

but am I just not going to use

the internet?

Like there's so many things.

Am I, am I going to,

drive down to city hall every time i

have a question about like my voter

registration i just it's it's ridiculous

this idea of like just don't use it

it's okay so i'll just never travel

because spirit might sell my date my

medical data for ai training like do i

just never get a job because i don't

want my data to get sold it's oh

my god

We so need better privacy laws because the

fact that this is even being debated,

approved,

is first of all mind-blowing to me.

But the fact that they're even having this

discussion is just like, no,

that should not be allowed.

People need a job.

People need to keep food on the table.

You should not be allowed to exploit that

and take their medical data for training

because they needed a job.

That's insane.

Getting off my rant.

Okay.

I will say, so real quick, Maria said,

I've started to purge Discord messages

older than six months.

Right now you're using a bunch of scripts.

The developer is very controversial.

I do want to be upfront about that.

I've been using a tool called Redact.

It's kind of expensive.

It's like,

I think it's like a hundred and twenty

bucks a year or something.

But I would promote something like

Clawback Your Data from Michael Lee.

But right now that one only does Twitter

as far as I know.

So Redact does do Discord.

And if there's any other services that do

Discord, let us know.

yeah jason just said that redact.dev can

do it but it is paid so yeah

i don't know um just to be clear

sid sid supports blue sky as well but

yeah oh okay okay yeah

Cool.

Yeah, it's hard finding ones that do,

reputable ones, I should say,

that do Discord and Reddit.

And I mean, to be fair,

those companies are constantly cracking

down and making the API,

like even in Redact,

every once in a while I open it

up and it's like, oh,

our Instagram deleter doesn't work right

now, which I don't use Instagram,

but I notice it.

It's like, oh,

our Instagram deleter is offline right now

because they changed their API and we have

to rework it.

And it's just like...

Good Lord.

And it's not their fault.

Meta is changing things all the time,

but it's ridiculous.

I love that about Mastodon.

I love that it just has the built-in,

like, yeah,

every three months or whatever,

just delete my stuff.

It's beautiful.

Yeah,

they should include more features like

that in Discord, but I will say...

I'm not going to tell you to break

Discord's terms of service and use

third-party tools,

but definitely do not use disk scrub and

definitely do not use that under any

circumstances.

So it's definitely not a good tool.

It's a terrible tool.

Anyway, so yeah,

so I think you should probably, you know,

use what's available if that means...

Maybe that could mean not using that tool.

Definitely don't use it.

But, like, you know,

there's options that are available, right,

that may break Discord's terms of service.

So, yeah,

we definitely don't recommend that,

though.

But it should be a feature that should

exist inside the actual application,

which is frustrating.

So...

Yeah,

Mastodon has spoiled me for that now.

Even though they're the only ones I've

seen that offer it, I've just gotten so...

Well,

and I guess Signal auto-delete messages.

But between those two,

and those are probably the two platforms I

use the most, I've gotten so spoiled now.

What do you mean it just doesn't delete

itself after a month?

This is insane.

Yeah.

I guess we do have...

There were some questions that were left

after last week's show from Torsten.

I just wanted to quickly...

highlight um we didn't answer some of them

on the actual show itself but i guess

we can quickly pop back onto that um

because i did want to quickly they did

write out quite a few big comments and

i did say that we would talk about

it on stream so um and they are

a member so i think we we should

do that but uh yeah yeah i didn't

even see this let's do it

Last week,

they left some comments after the show and

they said using uBlock Origin in nightmare

mode is actually possible and they do use

it with that and it does work.

So that was an interesting thing.

Basically, they kind of said like,

you know,

blocking JavaScript is not black and

white.

You block everything by default and then

create an allow list, which I think is...

good right they said like that's like the

opposite of badness enumeration and it's

great for security like if you don't trust

things by default and then you only allow

the things that you do trust it's it

is kind of a better way to do

it it is better for security to do

that way um

So that is one interesting thing.

I think we did talk about that a

little bit.

But they said, you know,

if you make backups of your config and

you're visiting websites that you go to

quite often and you know what you've set

it up correctly every time,

it can be not too much of a

pain.

So that is something they recommended to

do.

Yeah, I do agree when...

Just real quick,

when I used to do uBlock Origin,

if you're the kind of person who visits

the same sites for the most part,

then yeah, after a while,

you get it kind of dialed in and

you don't really have to think about it

anymore.

I know there's also...

Because uBlock has like five or six

different modes.

Again, check their wiki.

It's amazing.

It's super helpful.

And I think one of them is basically

like it blocks third-party JavaScript but

allows first-party, which is...

If you're hardcore enough to think about

blocking JavaScript,

but you're worried about it,

that's probably a good place to start.

Because in my experience,

that one causes a lot less breakage.

Still some, but yeah,

if you block everything by default,

like he says here,

it's like the web mostly doesn't work

without JavaScript anymore.

So maybe start with that and try it

out.

But yeah, that was a good comment.

I guess to move on to the next

comment, they left a second one.

Um, and this one was specifically,

we did talk a bit about Bluetooth last

week and, you know,

they kind of said like, yeah,

noise is horrible.

And, you know, over the, over the ear,

uh,

noise canceling headphones really do take

the stress out.

Um, and basically we said like, you know,

we,

there was one discussion where we talked

about like the Sennheiser Momentum four

headphones, uh,

always have Bluetooth enabled,

even if you connect it via like cable

and stuff, which is kind of a problem,

right?

So it is frustrating,

but they kind of said we shouldn't like

defend that sort of behavior.

And I agree.

I like, I don't think that's,

I think that is a bit silly and

a bit like,

don't know user like their headphones like

they don't require power to operate like

you know so it's it's kind of frustrating

that well i guess they do have power

like technically through the cable but

like you know not like they don't need

to be having a battery and powered on

at all times right so i don't know

if you have any thoughts on that one

quick but i don't remember that one at

all actually which is weird because i have

momentum these are momentum sports but i'm

sitting here i'm like why don't i remember

this

Um, but yeah, no, I agree with you.

If they're wired headphones,

I don't know what reason they would need

for Bluetooth or very least.

Uh,

cause I know there's like some headphones

that you can like take the wire out

and make them wireless at very least you

should be able to,

to like turn off the Bluetooth when

they're plugged in.

Cause yeah, that's, that's wild.

I don't know why they would be on

all the time.

Um, he did make a note here about,

uh, on updates.

They're very often not available.

Always require proprietary apps that spy

on you and need internet access and are

totally intransparent can confirm.

I do have the, um,

the Sennheiser app on my phone,

which is in a private space that is

off.

Ninety-nine percent of the time.

But yeah, like,

I don't think I've ever once seen an

update for these things in that app.

It's super annoying,

but I still fired up once every couple

of months and like, Hey,

are there any updates?

Nope.

Okay.

So, yeah, that's bad.

Oh,

I see somebody here commented about

removing image metadata.

Somebody actually emailed me.

Apparently,

Scrambled Exif is still getting updates,

just very infrequently.

So I'm not sure where I heard that

it was deprecated,

or maybe I just assumed that because it

hadn't had updates in a while.

But yeah, correction there.

And they also recommended an iOS app.

Yeah, I haven't messed with that.

I haven't heard of that one.

Oh, yeah,

Torsten mentioned alternative to .net,

which is a great resource.

I'm sorry, what?

Yeah,

I guess that is something we can look

into for the website.

I don't know exactly.

That's a really good question.

It's hard.

I try to make sure I know everything

that's on the website,

but there's a lot of stuff on the

website now.

So I'm not sure exactly what we recommend

specifically for that.

So maybe that's something that I can

quickly check while you add something more

there.

I mean,

if it makes you feel any better,

I wrote the new oil and I don't

even remember what's on there all the

time.

Like I joke with people that I made

that website just as much for me as

for anybody else.

Cause like, I don't know, man,

I can't remember everything.

There's so much to remember with all this

stuff.

So it's a,

I think that's fair to say.

Like it's,

Man, what would that be under?

I'm on the website now and I'm thinking

like,

what would metadata removal be under?

Yes.

So it's in recommendations and software.

There's a section for data and metadata

redaction.

So specifically we do recommend MAT too,

which basically is like cross-platform

software that allows you to remove

metadata.

It's a command line and graphical user

interface.

And yeah,

which is cool.

And then there's also a metadata cleaner,

which is one on Linux,

which I believe is available as a flat

pack.

So that's interesting as well.

Exif eraser on Android.

And I know for iOS,

there's just a shortcut that you can

create.

that just works through you know the stock

operating system so you can find that on

our website if you go to data and

metadata reduction it's in the

recommendations under software so

definitely check that out if you're on ios

there's a shortcut it works perfectly fine

to do that we also recommend exif tool

the cli version so those are kind of

all the options that we have and

I don't know about Scrambled Exif.

I guess I think it was originally listed,

but it might have been removed because of

that reason, but...

Yeah,

I think it probably went a long time

without updates.

And I think Exif Eraser is probably like

the continuation.

I could be wrong if that's a from

scratch project.

Yeah.

I will also say if you're a Signal

user,

the quick and dirty trick is just to

send yourself the image on Signal.

It's not great if you want to,

because I think Signal,

you would be more of an expert on

this than I would,

but I think Signal does have some

compression, right?

So if you want to preserve high quality

photography for a portfolio,

that's probably not the right option.

But if you're just like,

I'm just going to throw this photo up

on Mastodon and I just want to make

sure I didn't accidentally include

geotagging, yeah, Signal will work.

Definitely.

Anyways.

Yeah, that's all I got.

Yeah, I mean,

there's not much more here that was

discussed.

There was some...

They linked a discussion that was

happening on the Graphene OS forum,

and it was specifically people being

frustrated with the headphone jack not

being available on any of Graphene OS's

supported devices, which I kind of get it.

Like, I don't know.

Headphone jacks are nice, but also just...

I don't know, like maybe I'll become,

maybe I'll be crucified for this, but, uh,

USB-C, like I just used USB-C headphones.

I don't know.

Like it just a different,

it seems to work fine.

Like I know that there's like,

there's a digital to analog conversion

happening there.

That's probably really bad or whatever,

but like,

I can't really tell the difference.

Um,

So I'm not really sure.

I've found it to not be a huge

issue.

And I kind of like just having wireless

headphones.

They're just kind of convenient and they

just work quite well.

So it's never been a huge concern for

me to have.

specifically wired headphones,

but I do have like some AirPods that

use USB-C and it works perfectly fine

whenever I've needed that functionality.

So I don't know.

It is one thing that some people want,

but it seems like the majority of people

have kind of moved on from this sort

of thing.

And that's why phone manufacturers don't

include it anymore because it's just not

something that people want.

So...

Yeah, I mean,

the only time I really don't want wired

headphones is when I'm editing a video if

I have headphones in for some reason

because there's that lag and it makes it

hard to cut reliably.

And I don't do as much music editing

as I used to.

But yeah, if I was editing music,

I wouldn't use Bluetooth headphones.

But I actually moved away from wired

headphones.

Up until a few years ago,

I used wired headphones.

I was very happy with them.

Um,

not necessarily because they were wired,

but just because I was like, ah,

I'm not going to upgrade for no reason.

Um, but yeah, then at my last job,

it was such a physical job and I

do a lot of, you know,

listening to podcasts and listening to

music and like,

even just keeping one headphone in and I

was constantly catching the cable on stuff

or like, even,

even if I like ran it down my

shirt to try and keep it out of

the way, it just,

it was such a pain.

And, um,

I think actually my headphones broke.

If I remember correctly,

my headphones broke the cabled ones and I

borrowed my wife's headphones just for a

couple of days until I got new ones.

Cause I was like, babe,

I cannot work in silence.

Please let me use your headphones.

And just, they were wireless.

And I was just like, all right,

I'm sold.

This is amazing.

So the convenience is just too much for

me.

It's, I don't know.

I'm just not,

I know that's weird coming from an audio

guy who likes music,

but like if I'm listening to music because

I want to pick out every little detail,

then I'm going to do it at home

with my, my good speakers.

Like,

when I'm just out running errands and I

just want some like podcasts and music,

some something.

So I,

I don't hear whatever garbage is playing

on the grocery store radio.

Like I don't need it to be high

def, man.

I just, it's fine.

Yeah, exactly.

I think it also,

like someone also mentioned here, um,

It's all the wireless headphones lobbying

fault.

I mean, to be honest,

I feel like as soon as we had

the AirPods, like the first gen AirPods,

it literally killed everything.

It just killed wired earbuds.

It just completely annihilated it.

I think that's kind of the problem, right?

Because these...

products are so convenient and they're so

good at what they do like they're just

simple to use and they don't like you

know the convenience is too high for

people to just consider using wired ones

again it's kind of like if you ask

the majority of people would you buy wired

earbuds they would just say no they would

say absolutely not like it's just it's

just become that way um unfortunately and

I've kind of I'm I'm on that boat

like I

I prefer someone here said,

do you use a USB wired headphones for

voice on Graphene OS?

What's the max security choice in exploit

setting allowed with wired headphones?

There is like,

I believe because it's actually sending

data through the connection,

it actually does need to have like the

data when your device is,

what do you call it?

Unlocked, right?

Like charging only when locked,

I believe is what it would need to

be.

If you set it to charging only,

I'm not sure.

That is a good question, actually.

I was going to say,

I think if you set it to the

default would probably work,

which is basically like you just need to

unlock it at first so it can make

that handshake and then it's fine.

Yeah,

I think that's where you might have the

issues.

If you turn it to charging only mode,

then there's no data that's allowed

through,

which is where that would probably not

work.

So again, like the default setting,

charging only when locked is kind of what

you want to keep it at because it

needs to have...

that connection, like Nate said,

like the handshake.

So that is kind of important.

I wouldn't like personally,

I've never really used them much with my

phone.

I find I use them mainly with a

computer and the computer doesn't have,

that I have doesn't have any,

does it have any?

Oh no, it does.

It has a headphone jack.

So I guess I could use that,

but I don't know.

I just like,

I just put it into the USB.

Like I just have them.

So I don't know.

I just, that's what I do.

So,

and then someone also said same for the

lack of SD cards for memory expansion.

I think SD cards have a lot of

problems in terms of like,

storage per se because again because it's

outside of the actual android's file

system it's not encrypted or like there's

issues with the encryption extending to

that device and it's harder for it to

be protected against uh attacks so that is

like a security concern and in a lot

of cases i remember this they added it

as like a option to expand the internal

storage of your device and it was causing

performance issues like even with really

fast sd cards so i'm not really super

sold on the idea of

expandable storage using SD cards.

Maybe there's some other storage format

that could be implemented that would be

much quicker and allow for better

flexibility.

But I don't know.

I think as soon as you start having

this be something that can be taken out

of the device kind of easily,

it does become somewhat of a security

issue around the Android file system.

Maybe there's a way to do that more

secure, but I don't know.

I don't have an opinion on that one,

to be honest.

I don't typically store a lot of stuff

on my phone.

Yeah,

it's definitely not an issue I've ever

had.

I always buy the lowest storage,

and I've never once in my entire life

got anywhere close to it.

So I'm not sure what people use their

phone for,

but clearly I'm not the target audience.

So maybe I shouldn't have an opinion on

that, but...

Hopefully there's something that has that

feature for you because it seems like it's

something you really want.

So I hope there's something that comes out

that's going to meet those demands that

you have.

All righty.

Any other thoughts, questions,

comments before we close out?

I think we should probably close out the

episode where we're closing in on two

hours right now.

So we will be ending out the show

now.

All the updates from this week in privacy

will be shared on the blog every week.

So sign up for the newsletter or subscribe

with your favorite RSS reader if you want

to stay tuned.

We also offer a podcast available on all

podcast platforms and RSS,

which now includes a video on supported

platforms.

And this video will also be synced to

PeerTube.

Privacy Guides is an impartial nonprofit

organization that is focused on building a

strong privacy advocacy community and

building the best digital privacy and

consumer technology rights advice on the

internet.

If you want to support our mission,

then you can make a donation on our

website at privacyguides.org.

slash donate.

You can also make a donation on any

page on the website by clicking the red

heart icon located in the top right hand

corner of the page.

You can contribute using standard fiat

currency via debit or credit card or opt

to donate anonymously using Monero or with

your favorite cryptocurrency.

Becoming a paid member unlocks exclusive

perks like early access to video content,

exclusive video content,

a private signal chat where most of the

team is pretty active,

and priority during the This Week in

Privacy live stream Q&A.

You'll also get a cool badge on your

profile in the Privacy Guides forum and

the warm,

fuzzy feeling of supporting independent

media.

Thanks for watching.

And remember, there's no stream next week,

so we will see you in two weeks

on December fourth.

Have a great holiday.