what we can learn from the viral nvidia
saga graphene eleven graphene's pixel
eleven support is finally possible
asterisk and is it good that the average
person doesn't care about privacy quite a
hot take all this and more coming up
on this week in privacy number seventy
nine so stay tuned
Welcome back to This Week in Privacy,
our weekly series where we discuss the
latest updates with what we've been
working on within the Privacy Guides
community and this week's top stories in
data privacy and cybersecurity while
answering viewer questions.
I'm Jordan and this week with me is
Nate.
How's it going, Nate?
Not so bad.
I can't complain.
Could be worse, right?
Could be raining.
How have you been?
Yeah, good.
Really excited to dive into the stories
this week.
We've definitely got some interesting ones
this week.
Very interesting.
Really excited.
Yeah, for sure.
Let's go ahead and dive in.
We're going to talk about the big story
that everybody's been talking about this
week, which is the NVIDIA scandal.
But we are a privacy podcast,
so we're not going to get into a
lot of the juiciest details.
We're going to kind of focus on what
we can learn from a privacy and security
perspective here.
But believe it or not,
I think even though,
as far as I know,
none of us watching are CEOs of
billion-dollar, trillion-dollar companies,
I think there's still something we can all
learn.
But anyways,
so for any of you who have not
heard this story,
the headline here says – this comes from
Ars Technica.
It says,
NVIDIA CEO's affair becomes a national
security problem.
And –
There's, again,
there's like a million different outlets
covering this,
and there's a million different angles to
this,
but we're going to try to keep it
limited to privacy and security.
So basically, NVIDIA's chief executive,
Jensen Wang,
has admitted to having an affair two days
after the Financial Times reported his
alleged romantic relationship with a woman
the U.S.
intelligence community believes was
working as a spy for China.
The Financial Times reported on Friday,
for the record, Ars Technica just said FT.
I'm assuming that's Financial Times,
and I apologize if I get it wrong.
The FT reported on Friday that the U.S.
believed Wang had a romantic relationship
with a Chinese woman who was recruited to
spy for China's Ministry of State Security
Intelligence Agency.
American officials this year wrote a memo
based on information from U.S.
intelligence,
which said the NVIDIA boss had been
romantically involved with Alice Wang.
No relation.
That's actually,
her name is something completely different
in Chinese.
That's just like an Americanized version
of her name.
An executive at Megaspeed,
which is a Singapore-based customer of
NVIDIA,
according to people familiar with the
document.
Sorry, this isn't a quote.
So yeah, most people, again,
if you follow the news,
you probably know the broad strokes of
this story, as well as the memes.
Since this original Ars Technica article
came out,
Wong has since admitted to having two
additional affairs with NVIDIA employees
and has since stepped down as CEO of
NVIDIA,
which I'm going to be a little bit
snarky and say that's impressive that he
can be carrying on with four women and
run a company as CEO.
I guess he's just not that busy at
work.
I've seen a lot of jokes about how
we can replace him with AI, but...
Uh, I'll, I'll, I'll get off the snark.
I don't,
I don't know if I've had enough coffee
today for that or maybe too much coffee,
but, um,
I'm going to turn it over to Jordan.
I know that it's a pretty short story,
but I know, um,
Jordan especially had a lot of thoughts on
this one.
So I'm going to turn it over to
you and say, uh, again,
most of us watching this are probably not
CEOs and super high powered people.
So what can the average person who is
probably unlikely to be honeypotted by a
state intelligence agency take away from
this story in your opinion?
I mean,
I think the first thing that's kind of
obvious to most people,
I would hope is obvious,
is that the biggest issue with
security is almost never the actual
software itself.
It's actually a human that actually makes
the mistake, right?
So in this case,
it was obviously we can't really relate
this to the average person because like
Nate said,
you're not going to be targeted by like
a state-sponsored spy, right,
to be honeypotted.
That's just never going to happen to the
average person that doesn't have this
level of unprecedented control, right?
Because the person we're talking about,
like NVIDIA is like,
the largest or if not one of the
largest companies in the world with,
you know,
quite a significant sway over massive
industries right now, like AI,
like data centers, just all of this stuff,
right?
So it makes sense that he was targeted
in this way.
But coming back to the actual, like,
takeaways that are actually useful for
people, right?
You know,
the main concern that I think most people
should be should be concerned about is is
the human link,
because that's in a lot of ways the
way that people do get exploited right
through, you know,
phishing attacks and all sorts of things
like this instead of like, you know.
vulnerability in the software that you use
getting exploited by some hacker right
because that's just less likely for a
single individual to be targeted in that
way um so i think in this case
like this one guy who as far as
we know has like pretty pretty he has
access to pretty confidential information
within the company getting targeted by um
you know
state-sponsored spies is it makes a lot
more sense than, you know,
someone trying to actually exploit
someone's device because, you know,
I'm sure that he has personal and
professional devices lying around and
that's another vector that could have been
exploited, right?
You know,
just plugging a USB that exploits it.
Having physical access to devices that
have sensitive information on them is much
easier than trying to find like a zero
day to hack someone's device or whatever,
right?
So
think that's like the main the main thing
that people should be thinking about right
is like how
are there vectors that are more easily
exploitable that you should be more
concerned about, right?
So I don't think the average person needs
to worry a huge amount about someone
trying to exploit their device in that
way.
But I think just basic security tips,
like don't plug a USB you find on
the ground into your computer,
stuff like this.
So I don't know.
This is one of these stories where it's
very based on the person's actual
experience
access to confidential information.
So, you know,
it's it's much more it's much less likely
for that to be a concern for like
people that are watching this podcast or
the average person.
Right.
So I guess I can throw it back
to you, Nate.
Like this could possibly be somewhat of a
national security concern.
Right.
Like because there's so many of these
chips everywhere and they're in, you know,
so many things.
Right.
Yeah,
I don't really keep up with that side
of politics to be honest with you.
But yeah,
I know there's – I think it's more
of an economic competitive thing,
which I mean I guess sure.
I could see how you can draw it
back to China's military strength as well.
And I'm not saying it's like a far
fetch.
I'm just saying like I think it's mostly
– the US is being really strict right
now about where chips can be sold.
Um, because, uh, yeah, because we're,
we're trying to stay ahead of China in
the AI arms race.
And, um, I've, I don't know, I'm not,
I,
when I say I don't really keep up
on it very well as like,
I know that Nvidia wasn't supposed to sell
chips to China,
but then I think like Jensen Wong
convinced Trump to like,
give them some kind of.
exception.
And now I just saw a story or
a headline today.
I didn't read the whole story,
but I saw a headline about how like
thousands of chips have turned up in
certain Chinese hardware.
And everybody's like, Hey,
what happened in video?
How did this happen?
And I'm like, I'm personally sitting here.
I'm like, I don't know.
Didn't you guys say he could, I just,
but maybe those,
he wasn't supposed to sell those chips.
I don't know.
But yeah, it's, um, I mean, it's,
I know this isn't really a, what,
what we're talking about here, but, uh,
The supply chain of chips is extremely
precarious right now,
in case you guys didn't know.
So yeah, I mean, in a way,
I think...
I guess what I'm getting at is I
feel like national security is not the
only concern there.
But yeah, I mean,
it is a big concern that somebody this
big,
that this industry that is so centralized,
which is, of course, not a good thing,
I would argue.
I mean, if somebody had access to...
jensen wong and i feel like i've said
this on the show before like generally
speaking china has a very different
version of military intelligence than the
u.s and western countries western
countries tend to focus on like how many
troops do you have where they're deployed
uh how many tanks do you have what
military technology do you have and china
cares about that stuff too but they also
generally tend to care about the big
picture like what is um
you know, what,
what does life look like for the average
everyday American or German?
And so even if she wasn't necessarily like
stealing chip secrets from him, you know,
it's still just having access to someone
that powerful is definitely concerning
from a national security perspective.
Sure.
So I don't know if that answered your
question very well, but yeah, it's,
it's a,
I think there's a lot of angles to
this and that's,
I think that's why it's been such a
big story.
So.
Right.
I think also the other thing is just,
you know,
we see a lot of these big like
elite tech CEOs who we just keep seeing
it over and over again.
Like they're not really following good
operational security.
They're like kind of being a little loose
with things, you know.
So it is kind of interesting.
Like I think this is one thing that
like organizations should probably take
note on.
Like, you know,
probably do a little bit of like
background vetting on people that,
you know,
that have significant access to the
company, right?
I don't know if that's,
maybe that's too far,
but like I feel like if it's such
a huge company with like such a massive
sway on, like you said,
like it is like an economic,
it's an economic thing.
who has access to the chips, basically,
who can build AI faster,
which is currently kind of the situation,
at least.
So, yeah,
I think definitely some more security
policies could have been in place with
that, like, you know.
And, yeah, I'm not really...
I don't really have too many thoughts,
like, about the politics of this, because,
again, this isn't, like,
a political podcast.
We're just talking about the privacy and
security issues here.
So I think...
that's sort of like everything that I
think can be taken away from the
situation.
Um,
as far as like takeaways for like the
average person, I think just, yeah,
being more skeptical of a lot of things
that you see, um, you know,
humans are the weakest link, like,
you know,
phishing links and stuff like that.
Uh, social engineering,
all sorts of things like that.
That's
something that the average person can be
targeted by.
In the end,
this was like a social engineering attack
in some ways, because this lady,
she used her ability to
you know,
get into a romantic relationship with the
CEO to gain access to privileged
information.
So that is social engineering in a way.
And it's certainly possible that someone
could do the same thing to you,
but I think it's less of a concern
for people that don't have access to,
you know, such a huge corporation.
Yeah, for sure.
We did have a couple of questions.
Somebody commented about the interim CEO.
I don't know much about her.
I saw that apparently she was like one
of the few people in the C-suite who
was willing to push back on Jensen's
ideas.
Yeah.
I don't know.
The way that I read that article was
like in a very adversarial sort of way.
But that's in my opinion,
that's a good thing at a company,
especially when you have somebody like
Jensen Wong, who's got this like,
all right,
we're going to aim for like screw the
moon.
We're going to aim for Jupiter.
And somebody is like, OK,
and how are we going to get out
of the atmosphere?
Like,
I think that's a good thing to have
in a person.
But I don't know much about her.
I don't know much about her connections or
her.
I know she's the CFO,
the financial officer.
So I don't know.
I don't I don't really have an opinion
on that story personally.
um i don't know if you have anything
to say about that um somebody said in
the chat uh they missed the mastodon live
stream oh yeah i think i might have
accidentally scheduled it for tomorrow
instead of today um i think they just
said they see it now so they see
it now okay um
Yeah, no,
I'm not sure what happened there.
Again,
like it is kind of tricky with time
zones.
Like for me, it's Saturday.
For Nate, it's Friday.
It's a completely different like it's like
a different day.
So sometimes it does get confusing.
So sorry about that.
If you didn't see that,
it should be it should be live now.
And then like our scheduling software for
some reason doesn't always switch time
zones like mine is set to the wrong
time zone.
Only by like an hour but I didn't
know that one time I think I was
filling in for you so I like scheduled
all the posts and everything.
And it like posted halfway through the
podcast because I didn't realize I was an
hour off so.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I schedule the posts using the US time.
And then in the actual app,
it shows the Australian time.
It's like, ah, it's confusing.
It's really confusing.
So I'm sorry if that happens.
So yes, again, apologies for that.
But it should be live now.
Yeah.
And then last one, um,
somebody asked if we think prices are
going to come down like prices of Ram.
Uh, I doubt it,
but I know Nvidia stock price has already
fallen.
I'm sure it'll bounce back.
I don't know.
We'll, uh, we'll see what the new,
new CFO slash CEO intern CEO does.
So, um,
Yeah, I don't know.
I think that's all I've got on that
story.
Somebody said there's stories coming out
about how there's far more RAM and GPU
silicon supply than there is demand.
And that implies current price gouging is
entirely artificial.
You know what?
It honestly wouldn't surprise me.
I haven't heard that.
But I mean,
we know that the diamond industry has done
that.
I mean,
a lot of industries have done that,
including ones you would be very surprised
by.
So I don't have a comment,
but it absolutely would not surprise me
personally.
But unless you have anything else to add
to that one,
I've been keeping an eye on some of
the chats.
We don't have any questions in the forum
yet or the Signal chat.
I don't think there's been anything in
Fluxer either.
So I think we can probably move on
to our first forum post, if you're ready.
Awesome.
Yeah, let's dive into this forum post.
So as usual, just so everyone knows,
we do have a community forum at
discuss.privacyguides.net.
And we usually talk about like, you know,
two or three posts that we see every
week.
So this one here is about someone who's
having an issue with a ring camera.
So the title is,
my new apartment neighbor installed a ring
camera pointed directly at my door.
What should I do?
My city has a high crime rate,
but I live in a very safe area
of town in a suburban apartment complex.
My building is in the back part of
the complex, furthest from the road.
I'm just going to skip some of this
because I don't want to publicly share
exactly everything about what they said
because of privacy reasons.
I've lived here for years and never had
any concerns about safety.
Neighbors have left packages by their door
for days in plain sight and nothing goes
missing.
You're more likely to get a letter from
management threatening fines for creating
an eyesore by leaving packages out than to
have a package stolen.
A new neighbor directly across the hall
moved in.
I haven't actually met them yet,
but they installed a ring camera and
they're the only unit that has a camera
doorbell in my building.
I've noticed a few camera doorbells in
other buildings,
but ninety nine percent of units don't
have a camera.
The camera points directly at my door,
my window and my outdoor closet.
I can't open my door,
open my blinds or open my closet without
being recorded.
What do you people suggest that I do?
This is really tricky.
This is one of these circumstances where
it's sort of a human issue and you
can't really solve that simply.
Right.
I think basically most people are
suggesting, you know,
talking to the neighbor,
trying to be good faith,
trying to actually be reasonable.
in your request and try and find,
you know,
a compromise between so you can both be
happy, right?
You can have the camera mounted in a
way where it doesn't film your direct
door, for instance.
You know,
make sure to document everything and
involve management if it becomes
difficult.
the worst, you know, if it goes,
if it goes badly involve management.
But I guess I'll throw it back to
you, Nate.
Like,
is this something you've ever dealt with?
Is this like,
do you have any suggestions on like how
to deal with this sort of thing?
Um, no,
we did have at my last apartment, um,
we did have the downstairs neighbor had a
ring doorbell that was kind of facing, um,
actually I think it was nest,
but they had one of those,
those cameras that was like,
it was mounted up in the ceiling,
but because of the layout of the
apartment,
I had to walk past it to get
anywhere.
Um,
and unfortunately I did ask management and
they said that there's no rules against,
cause I've lived in some apartments where
you're actually not allowed to have, um,
video doorbells, which is awesome.
But yeah,
they said there's nothing they can really
do.
And my solution was just because I would
leave early in the morning anyways.
And usually I would I would bring my
thing is one of my little pet peeves
is when it rains and the rain gets
on my glasses.
And, you know,
then it's like I can't see.
So a lot of the time I'll bring
a hat instead of an umbrella because I
don't.
really care as long as it's not like
pouring obviously i don't really care if
like my shirt gets a little wet just
keep it off my glasses so anyways what
i was gonna say is i would just
put my hat on um when i would
go to work in the morning and i
would just like look straight down at the
floor so that it wouldn't really catch my
face um but yeah it's uh
It's tricky.
I mean,
it's definitely it's a soft skills thing.
And, you know, again,
I've also said on the podcast,
one of my personal passing interests,
I guess you could say,
is like disaster prep.
So, you know,
we have a couple cases of bottled water
just in case the water needs to get
shut off or something.
We have some canned food.
We have a big thing of rice,
which I'm super happy about.
And,
and that is one thing that I personally
want to get better at is like meeting
my neighbors and being on good terms with
my neighbors.
Cause that can help out, you know,
if somebody is like, Hey,
like this delivery guy came up earlier
today and he's kind of sniffing around
your place.
And I asked him what he needed and
he just like left, you know,
like somebody who can kind of look out
for you.
But yeah,
I don't know how to do it.
I need to ask my wife cause she's
a wizard at just making friends with
everybody all the time.
But yeah,
Yeah, again,
it's definitely a soft skills thing,
and...
I think most people are generally pretty
nice.
Like,
that's something I've also heard that a
lot of international people say is that
Americans are generally really nice
people.
And, yeah,
trying to meet them in this case of,
like, look,
I know you're worried about your safety.
Don't come at them with, like, the whole,
like,
I've lived here for years and nothing as
bad has ever happened.
But just, like, hey,
I respect that you care about your safety
and you're worried about that stuff.
But, like, I don't know.
I just feel weird that this thing is
pointed right at me.
Can we find some kind of compromise?
So...
It's tough, for sure.
But yeah, that's kind of all I got.
I don't know if anybody in the chat
has any better ideas about that one.
Yeah,
it's definitely worth looking at your
specific laws in the area that you live
because something like this might be
illegal depending on where you live.
I'm not sure if that's the case.
I'm assuming that's probably not the case
where this person lives because they're
asking the question anyway.
I think they did say they were in
the US, so...
I don't know if you can confirm or
deny whether that's actually allowed or
not.
Well, in the U.S., yes.
But again,
it could depend on the apartment complex.
Some may have a policy against that.
And also, their particular state could...
I don't know.
The fact that it is facing right into
their unit could definitely be a thing.
I'm not sure.
I'm not a lawyer,
especially for that state.
But yeah,
that is definitely something worth
checking out.
Somebody said in the patron chat that...
My,
my wife's secret to meeting people is
ADHD.
So apparently I just need to have more
ADHD and then I can, yeah,
I don't know if that,
I don't know if that's, yeah,
I guess so.
Uh,
I mean, she definitely does.
She has ADHD.
But anyways, yeah,
we did actually have a question from
somebody saying,
do we have any thoughts about the Graphene
OS tweet saying Pixel XI support is
delayed?
Ironically enough,
that is actually our very next story.
We're going to talk about the Pixel XI
and the Graphene situation.
I mean,
I guess we can dive into it right
now.
So Graphene OS announces Pixel-Eleven
support can be completed now.
Graphene OS announced on their Blue Sky
that Android-seventeen QPR-Two is
releasing with MTE support for
Pixel-Eleven phones,
and they've confirmed it works with
Graphene OS.
Despite the security improvements the
Pixel XI phones bring,
like QuantumSafe Secure Boot and improved
Titan III security chip,
they shipped without MTE support,
so Graphene OS couldn't be ported to the
new phones.
Now the final piece from Google looks to
be in place for them to be able
to properly support Pixel XI devices once
Android-XVII QPR-II releases.
However, like this person said,
there's been an update,
it's been indefinitely delayed due to
Google not pushing sources for Android,
as promised.
Not pushing QPR one and QPR three and
monthly releases is awful,
but now it appears they're going to be
delaying yearly and QPR two releases.
We'll have to consider that before
supporting those.
So that's what they said.
We can easily work around the monthly
releases not being pushed,
but QPR when and QPR three are major
hassle.
It ends up causing regressions,
which are hard to resolve since we still
have to ship the new firmware,
drivers and HALS.
But those aren't designed to work with an
older release.
Okay.
So, I guess, throwing this to you, Nate,
what are we thinking and does this really
affect the attractiveness of the new
Motorola device that's coming out soon?
Yeah, I mean,
that's kind of something I've really been
struggling with is, you know,
like Golden PJ said here,
and I'm sure you guys covered this last
week, is like, man,
that's sixteen hundred dollars is quite a
lot in this economy.
And the thing about it is like for
graphene users,
typically graphene users don't want all
the, you know,
the AI features and all the fancy stuff.
that a phone of that hardware would, yeah,
that that kind of hardware would support.
So it's really,
it's almost like paying sixteen hundred
dollars to get an eight hundred dollar
phone or maybe even less.
I don't know.
I'm not good with hardware,
but I'm a software guy.
But yeah, so it's kind of frustrating.
But on the one hand,
there's that side of me that's like,
It shows that there's a demand for a
non-Google graphene alternative,
like if you were to buy it.
And I mean I keep seeing people say
that Motorola has a habit of these –
these Motorola phones have a habit of like
going on serious discount shortly after.
So I mean maybe in a couple of
months, it may be eight hundred dollars,
and that might be a little bit –
Easier to stomach.
I don't know, because, yeah,
it seems like Google,
intentionally or otherwise,
I hesitate to attribute everything to
Malice right off the bat,
but it's certainly possible.
It seems like Google is just constantly
putting up more and more obstacles for
these custom OSs,
and it's almost like they don't want to
come out and admit that they don't want
to be open anymore,
but they just don't want to be open
anymore.
And, yeah,
it does kind of make you wonder, like,
how much longer, even if they want to,
how much longer can Graphene keep
supporting these?
But it's...
I also have concerns about the hardware.
The Titan M series is a really,
really solid chip.
It's been time-tested and proven,
and I don't necessarily know that the
Signature XXVII is going to have the same
level of hardware protection.
So I don't know, man.
It feels like we're in between a rock
and a hard place right now,
to be honest.
Yeah,
it's definitely – Google is definitely
putting a –
putting a dent in, in Graphene OS's plans.
Uh,
and it does seem like either they've laid
off people that usually do the work to
get these releases out, or, you know,
like you said,
there's possibly some sort of malice in,
and, and, you know, uh,
you know, negative intent, right?
But we don't really know exactly what's
happening because we don't, you know,
we're not inside Google.
We don't really know,
like they're thinking, oh,
we can destroy Graphene OS.
Like they're probably not thinking that.
They're probably just having issues
getting those releases out because of the
amount of stuff that they've laid off or
some other reason.
And it unfortunately- I was going to say
too much AI.
Yeah.
Too much AI.
I mean,
you would think that they would probably
get it out quicker if they had the
AI, but I mean, maybe not.
Maybe that's not helping them.
I don't know.
I was going to say,
unless it's breaking everything like it is
for Microsoft, who knows?
So far, it hasn't.
But I do get concerned with Google because
they do seem very, very into Google.
We did get a comment here from...
hello six four four six um how do
you browse the internet with disabled
javascript almost every website a visit
needs it to work enabling javascript on
every website after disabling it by
default leaves a bait a bad taste in
my mouth and is practically a waste of
time i feel like you have some thoughts
on this nate so i'm gonna i'm gonna
let you answer this one
What is that supposed to mean?
I do though, actually.
Yes.
No.
So I,
in the past I've experimented with a lot
of different configurations of things
like, like you block origin in, in,
I think they call it.
It's either hard mode or nightmare mode.
Um, cause if you guys didn't know,
they're,
they're not built into you block origin,
but if you check their official
documentation on GitHub,
they have a very great wiki by the
way on GitHub that I totally recommend
that explains everything about how it
works.
It's super enlightening.
Um,
but they explained that they have
different modes.
Uh, and, uh, like, I think it's, again,
it's like one of the hardest modes is
basically like all JavaScript script
disabled.
Um,
I would say depending on how you're
browsing the internet with JavaScript
disabled, yeah, I agree with you.
I found it to be much more trouble
than it was worth,
and I kind of don't think it is
worth it anymore just because, yeah,
you end up going in and enabling stuff
anyways.
I think from a security perspective,
I know you usually have to go into
either like the about config on Firefox or
the Brave flags,
or you can just use Movad browser,
but you can disable like...
like just-in-time JavaScript,
which I know that goes a long way
towards reducing attack surface.
If anybody's willing to go tinker with
that kind of stuff,
that's probably the easiest compromise.
If you're using something where you can
block specific scripts, again,
like you block origin,
I would say just focus on blocking
third-party stuff.
In my experience,
there's a lot less breakage there.
Although I do want to point out that
there have been a lot of,
I would say, speculation.
I don't know how proven it is,
but there is this idea that...
depending on what you block,
that could turn into a way to fingerprint
you.
Because if you're the only person who's
blocking third-party JavaScript,
which I mean, you're not, but just,
I mean,
that's why they changed Privacy Badger,
right?
Like Privacy Badger used to learn as you
browse the web,
it would notice if certain things were
tracking you and it would block them.
But then somebody alerted EFF, it's like,
hey, you know,
this is creating a unique fingerprint for
everybody, right?
So it doesn't do that anymore by default.
You can enable it, but by default,
it's just a block list.
Apparently some people didn't hear that
news.
So in case you didn't know,
I think that happened in like twenty
eighteen.
So, yeah, I don't know.
I would say just focus on like using
again something like you block origin,
just block like the major trackers like,
you know,
Google Analytics and stuff like that.
But yeah, in my experience,
blocking all JavaScript is really a lot
more hassle than it's worth,
in my personal opinion.
So.
Yeah, just to be clear,
the reason I said that was because you
have mentioned that you did really like
UMatrix in the past,
which I know definitely has some level of
JavaScript blocking built in or something.
That was a good plug-in.
I missed that one.
Yeah, I do too.
I did like it.
But I think that there is definitely...
you know,
things that you can think about about
risks, right?
Like,
every time you're browsing the internet,
like,
is this worth the actual trade-off of
having to basically, you know,
go through every website and make sure
that the JavaScript is enabled anyway?
It kind of breaks accessing the majority
of the internet.
And I think for basically the majority of
people,
that's a bit too much of a hassle
to deal with.
So...
But like, like Nate said,
like there's just in time.
There's also the other one that I don't
think you mentioned was the V eight
optimizer.
You can disable that.
And that also apparently reduces, um,
reduces the level of, uh,
access that JavaScript has.
Um,
I wasn't sure if that was the same
thing or not.
So, okay.
Good to know.
It could be, it could be,
it could be.
Um, yeah.
So V eight optimizer is another thing.
Um, and yeah,
I think there's not really much you can
do in terms of JavaScript these days.
I personally just leave it on and,
you know, make sure that I'm,
I think layering as well is also
important.
Like, you know, use ublock origin,
use DNS blocking,
have multiple layers of security in that
aspect.
And hopefully something,
if there is something malicious in terms
of JavaScript, it's blocked automatically.
But again, there's,
Someone here actually mentioned,
I stopped using an Adblock plugin out of
fingerprinting concerns and instead rely
on network level Adblock.
I believe that network level Adblock is
also fingerprintable because, you know,
your browser is not going to be able
to make certain connections when you go to
a website.
I'm not sure if that's actually the case
or not, but...
Yeah,
we'll definitely have to look into that
because I'm not a hundred percent sure on
the facts on that.
I, I don't know either.
I'm going to be honest.
I think for most of us who do
not have a particularly high threat model,
I think we're overthinking it a lot of
the time.
Like, yeah,
if you're blocking all JavaScript,
I think that... Because on the one hand,
I think a lot of fingerprinting scripts
require JavaScript.
Not all of them.
I have seen proofs of concept using CSS.
But I think most of them,
like Google Analytics, for example,
require JavaScript.
Yeah.
So in theory, by blocking JavaScript,
you couldn't be fingerprinted.
But at the same time, I don't know.
I think it's one of those things where...
We know so little about fingerprinting,
and we don't know...
what they put emphasis on.
Like companies,
it's funny because companies that talk
about fingerprinting, first of all,
if you look up browser fingerprinting,
you're gonna find nothing but like
analytics companies trying to score a new
client.
And so of course you can't really trust
them because of course they're gonna claim
that they have the world's most accurate
everything and that's why you should pay
us five billion dollars a month for our
stupid product that probably doesn't even
do anything.
So it's like nobody is talking about it
from the other side of the perspective
where they're like a whistleblower,
like yeah,
I used to work for this company.
Here is exactly how it works.
Here's exactly what we did.
Here's the differences between the
different things.
So it's honestly,
it's all just kind of guesswork.
And I think it's one of those,
like if, if you're doing like a basic,
um,
Even an ad blocker,
like I think a good ad blocker,
I mean,
I'm very biased against ads for a lot
of reasons.
That's kind of turning into my personal
crusade lately.
But I think it's better than just doing
nothing.
And I think there's like a balance.
Again, if you're blocking everything,
you're going to stand out.
But I think just adding uBlock Origin,
like everybody uses that and stuff like
that.
AdGuard Home, somebody pointed out.
Like I think the basic things that a
lot of people are using is probably not
that risky.
And if your threat model is really that
high where you're like, no,
I absolutely cannot afford to be
fingerprinted, you should be using Tor.
And then you blend in with everybody.
Like, I don't know.
I think it's one of those things that
we just kind of overthink a little bit
personally.
Yeah,
I think that's definitely a fair point.
I think the thing is with the DNS
ad blocking is websites can see what DNS
server you're using.
But again,
if you're using something like AdGuard or
Piehole, it forwards it.
It blocks it at the local level,
and then it forwards that to the actual
service that you want, right?
So I'm not sure if that would be...
That would probably be less
fingerprintable, I guess,
if you set it to Google or your
DNS, your ISP's DNS,
it wouldn't be as obvious.
Someone said Brave and AdGuard Home.
You can use all sorts of tools to
layer that protection.
I have a
I have a pie hole that uses AdGuard
as the DNS resolver.
So like you were saying,
like multiple levels of,
and I have some of the block lists
enabled,
some of the basic block lists enabled on
the pie hole.
So there's block lists,
there's individual things that I've gone
through and blocked.
And then there's AdGuard.
There's like three layers of defense
there.
So.
Um,
somebody said privacy guides forum is
unusable on the safest security level on
tour.
Yeah.
I mean,
most of the internet is unusable on the
safest security level, even, even on, um,
Moldad browser.
I've,
I've switched Moldad browser recently to
the, uh, the safer security level,
like the middle one.
And I was surprised how many things that
broke.
So unfortunately that's,
that's kind of the trade off.
Just to be clear about the forum though,
that's not down to us.
That's actually Discourse,
the forum software that we use.
They don't allow for disabling JavaScript
for it to work correctly.
I'm sure there's other forum softwares
that exist, but for our specific use case,
Discourse makes the most sense.
It works for our situation,
so we can't really switch to something
else.
But I can assure you there's no tracking
scripts.
There's no malicious JavaScript on the
forum.
So I don't think it's a huge issue
if you can't access it without that.
But again, if that's a concern,
then maybe I don't really know.
I don't really know what to say.
That's unfortunate.
Yellow discourse.
Yeah, go bug discourse about it.
I think we can move into our site
updates.
I think this is probably a good time
for that.
So yeah, in a little bit,
we're going to dive into a hot take
about how much the average person cares
about privacy.
But first,
we're going to give some quick updates on
what we've been working on at Privacy
Guides this week.
And remember to go ahead and leave your
questions and comments in the chat.
I see the chat is very active today.
And we will definitely get to some of
those in a moment.
But first,
I'm going to hand it over to Jordan
to talk about some of our more recent
changes.
You are muted, friend.
Sorry.
Yes,
so this week we've got some site updates
that we've pushed,
mostly just administrative stuff,
which was updating some issues with GitHub
Actions,
and it was mainly to fix some of
the different language versions that we
have of the site,
and that was mostly done by Daniel,
so that was good.
There was also a change to the Proton
mobile app audits,
which basically just updated some of the
wording.
Basically,
we mentioned that the Proton Drive web
application was independently audited in
the twenty twenty one.
And then we also added a section that
the Android and iOS apps underwent
independent security audits by the same
company in twenty twenty two.
And we linked to the source there as
well.
So that was a good update that someone
added as well.
That was good to get that added.
And as usual,
we do have news briefs every week.
That's freer and sometimes Nate does as
well.
So this week we had Microsoft Paint
vulnerability could allow attackers to
take over your computer.
Chat GPT lockdown mode bypass could leak
your chat history without your knowledge.
And Claude Code leaking secrets and
passwords in public GitHub repositories.
So all fun stuff there.
I guess I can throw it back to
you though, Nate.
What are we working on in terms of
video stuff?
Yeah, so I know you actually,
just as we jumped on here for the
live stream,
you are doing the final render of our
Graphene OS video,
which it's really just an overview about
what Graphene OS is and why we recommend
it for people,
even if they're not a state-level
politician or activist or journalist or
anything.
So hopefully there will be a good...
it'll be a good video that you can
share with like your friends and family
who may not be familiar with graphene and
kind of give them an overview of like,
here's some of the cool features.
And then I have mentioned several times
that we are also doing an Obtanium
tutorial, which is fully filmed.
And just last night, actually,
I went through and did the first cut
where I cut out all the mistakes and
dead space and everything.
So I just have to add some B-roll
like screenshots and screen grabs on my
end.
And then it will be off to Jordan
to add any, uh,
Last minute magic.
That one should be pretty straightforward,
I hope.
But it should be fun.
Yeah,
all this is made possible by our
supporters.
If you'd like to support us,
you can sign up for a membership or
donate at privacyguides.org,
or you can pick up some swag at
shop.privacyguides.org.
Privacy Guides is a nonprofit which
researches and shares privacy-related
information and facilitates a community on
our forum and matrix and Fluxer where
people can ask questions and get advice
about staying private online and
preserving their digital rights.
Now let's talk about how to
compartmentalize your social media
accounts.
And remember to leave your questions in
the chat and we will get to them
in between stories.
Actually,
real quick before we jump into that one,
somebody asked,
talking about the Proton audit,
isn't a little bit outdated at this point
because there have been so many changes
since then?
I don't know.
Do you have a thought on that one?
I think so.
I agree.
I think they should be doing more regular
audits.
And it is concerning that it's been
almost, I guess at this point, four years.
Four years.
So that is concerning to hear.
Obviously,
we do have not many recommendations.
when it comes to cloud providers.
So we kind of have to be a
bit, you know,
a little bit more lax when it comes
to that, right?
Because otherwise literally nothing would
be even like,
we would have nothing on there,
which I guess is,
we're trying to find the best possible
options.
And this Proton Drive,
even though they had the audit in
It's still, you know,
it's still one of these really good
services that hasn't shown that they can't
be trusted, at least.
But again,
we should be seeing another audit this
year, next year.
We need to see something soon because
again,
if it becomes
One of these things where it takes them
five years in between audits, it's like,
well, what's really the point?
Because like this person said, you know,
there has been so many changes and audits
are basically just a snapshot of that
specific time period, right?
We know in twenty twenty two that the
apps were secure.
But do we know in twenty twenty six
that they're still secure?
Probably not.
Right.
So that's when it becomes more tricky.
So I think they should be doing it
every year, ideally.
But again,
these sort of things are pretty,
pretty expensive.
So again,
maybe it's too maybe it's too extreme to
expect that every single year,
every two years seems reasonable to me.
But again,
I think this is one of these things
where if you want this to be a
requirement... Oh, what just happened?
My camera just went black.
Yeah, I still hear you.
I don't know where the camera went.
Interesting.
I'm not sure what's happening there.
Anyway,
what I was trying to say is if
you want this to be changed and if
you want this to become...
like part of a criteria,
I would really highly recommend you join
our forum and,
and open a thread and say like,
you know, this should be fixed.
It should be removed because of this.
Um, because we do,
that is the main reason why we make
changes is because of people in our
community that want things, um,
to be changed.
So yeah, that's,
that's what I would say to that.
Um, again,
we're not completely opposed to that
becoming, um, a thing.
I will just quickly disappear though.
Um, while I fix this.
All right,
I will go ahead and jump into our
next story then,
which is actually yet another forum
update.
I'm gonna be honest with you guys,
it was a little bit of a,
not so much a slow news week per
se,
but we try really hard to find a
balance between like big stories and
stories that actually like affect you
guys.
And there's something, you know,
like a takeaway for you guys.
And there just weren't a lot of those
stories this week.
So, well, Jordan's back.
I don't know,
did you wanna take this or you want
me to take this?
No, I'm good.
I can hop on it.
It's quick anyway.
This one was just like a post here
from someone saying they wanted to have
social media accounts,
but they wanted them to be safe,
I guess.
You know,
I want some to be public and others
I want to be anonymous.
Can I use the same email to create
all of them or is that compromising?
Do I have two separate emails for public
and anonymous accounts?
They're kind of overwhelmed, basically.
Facebook can be kind of awful when it
comes to signups,
like they don't allow proton mail,
for instance.
So...
yeah,
kind of just how to create things
anonymously or slash semi-anonymously,
like what sort of things should someone be
looking for?
Someone did in this post,
they did respond.
They said,
don't use the same email account in your
real name and pseudo anonymous accounts.
Don't use Instagram or the Facebook app
because they have significant access to
your information.
So yeah,
I will say that's first.
I guess I'll throw it to you, Nate.
There was another comment there as well
that someone suggested,
but do you have any thoughts on this
one?
Yeah, I mean, I actually,
this kind of inspired me.
I think I want to write a blog
post now.
I don't know when it'll come.
I've got a lot of blog posts in
the queue right now.
But this is a common concern,
even for people that aren't super into
privacy,
is people may want one account that they
just use for, I don't know,
shit posting or whatever,
and to another account that's like their
actual professional account or whatever.
And if you're not careful, like,
Facebook will go through and like
recommend you to ever.
I've told the story before about how like
back when I was single years, years ago,
this is like ten years ago,
I started talking to a girl and we
just texted a few times and then she
showed up on my Facebook is like people
you may know.
And I was like, cool, thanks, Facebook.
I feel like I'm stalking this girl now.
And Facebook's really aggressive with that
crap.
So it's one of those things where I
wouldn't say it's hard,
but it requires intentionality.
And yeah, a lot of people don't realize,
totally not trying to make fun of anybody
who doesn't know this stuff, by the way,
but I always kind of got annoyed by
like...
like back on r slash privacy,
back when I used to go there,
I would see people asking questions that
like, oh,
I signed up for Instagram and Amazon with
the same account or same username and
everything, like everything's the same.
And I don't understand why I'm seeing ads
for the thing I looked up on Amazon.
And it's like,
what do you mean you don't understand?
Like,
how do you not know that they can
tell that's you?
It's so obvious,
but a lot of people just don't think
about that kind of stuff.
And yeah,
it can be really overwhelming if, um,
especially if you're new to this stuff and
you're,
you're coming to it for the first time,
but yeah, things like, um,
using aliasing email to like separate the
accounts.
Um,
some people mentioned like using VPNs and
different browsers, um,
that would probably help different phone
numbers.
I mean,
really just kind of trying to complete,
uh,
trying to, Oh my God,
my brain just blanked on the word,
treat it,
trying to treat them as like separate
identities as much as possible,
which I know what the phone number thing
is really difficult, but yeah.
And it really just depends like what
you're like one person recommended cycling
accounts, like start a new account,
let it age three months,
then start using it while your usual
account fades into the past.
I mean,
that depends what you're trying to get out
of it, but yeah,
that is definitely one strategy for sure.
I see people have been leaving a lot
of
comments here.
Um,
somebody said it's difficult to get a
pseudonymous email account though.
I mean,
it depends who you go with and it
depends how pseudonymous, like it,
that's always the thing with threat
modeling, right?
Like, yeah,
if you want to make sure that the
NSA can't figure out who's behind that
account, that's going to be difficult.
But if you're just trying to keep like
LexisNexis from linking those two accounts
together, I mean,
I think just using different, uh,
like simple login emails would probably be
fine.
And yeah, like you said,
with no link at all between that and
your real identity,
that's definitely tricky.
Yeah,
somebody mentioned they could use
progressive web apps,
which are super underrated.
That's actually one of the reasons I
wanted to mention this story, I think.
Or maybe that's our last story.
I can't remember.
But yeah,
PWAs are something that they get mentioned
a little bit,
but I feel like people don't talk about
them enough, in my opinion.
Definitely.
I think also the other thing that I
really like is just separating devices,
like having separate devices for specific
purposes, right?
Because even if you do have to install
an app, right,
you've got it on a separate device.
It doesn't have the actual data there that
can be accidentally shared, right?
Because the last thing you want is to
accidentally...
accept contact permission on facebook and
now every single person in your in your
address book has been sent to facebook and
now they're suggesting all these people to
you because that is the way that they
they kind of connect you basically um your
contacts is is a big one so you
know that sort of thing i i'd say
separate devices if you can afford it
again it is one of those things where
it's like
an expense that not everyone can afford.
Again, we do recommend Graphene OS,
so you could do separate profiles for each
purpose.
That's another way to compartmentalize
things a little bit.
I guess when it comes to accounts,
I feel like Nate has already mentioned
everything.
So I don't really have anything to add
in terms of that, I would say.
I did see a comment from somebody here.
Yes.
It's also important to recognize whom you
are trying to separate.
Your identity,
much easier to register two Discord
accounts to separate friends and other
identities.
Yeah, so that's kind of the thing, right?
You know, having separate identities,
but for different people is one way to
do that.
I think it's...
it's definitely tricky when you start
meeting people in real life because,
you know, then you've got like, it's,
you can't really disconnect your,
your real like flesh body from to like,
if you understand what I'm trying to say,
like you're still the one person,
but you have two separate identities.
That's where it becomes trickier.
But again,
I think discord is one of those ones
where it's like,
Very frustrating to register, you know,
you need separate phone numbers and all of
that.
So again, like, you know,
stuff like MySudo or I think people in
the US like to use Google Voice for
that.
But again,
that also could be a concern because then
Google has access to that information.
So...
Separate prepaid SIM cards maybe as well.
I would recommend that especially because
a lot of these services require a phone
number on signup.
So again,
buying a separate SIM card specifically
for Instagram and Facebook that no one
else has that phone number.
It's guaranteed for you to not be...
um suggested to other people because of
your phone number so i think that's
definitely one way instagram and and
facebook kind of creates social maps of
you um someone here did to have a
comment though i think i'll throw this
back to you uh nate who slash what
is alexis nexus yeah lexus nexus is one
of the the big data brokers um so
a lot of the time when we talk
about like
Amazon and Facebook and Google collecting
your data,
typically they don't sell your data if we
want to be technical.
They run ads and they sell access to
your data.
However,
there are certain companies out there like
LexisNexis that one of their products is
that they –
um collect as much data as they can
and sometimes they will buy it from apps
you know especially a lot of these smaller
apps will sell your data to google or
lexus nexus or there's some other ones i
think axiom is one um and so they
are the ones that then a lot of
the time advertisers who can't collect
that data on their own so basically not
google not i mean sometimes google and
amazon and facebook will go to them but
Usually their advertising network and
their data collection networks are so
extensive they don't really need to.
But a lot of smaller companies will go
to LexisNexis and they'll buy – like I
actually remember back when I lived in
Texas, I got a mailer one time.
And for the record,
I was vegetarian at the time.
I got a mailer for a barbecue thing
that was like, oh,
your birthday is coming up.
Happy birthday.
Here,
come get like a fifty percent off or
something.
And I was like super pissed because number
one, barbecue for a vegetarian.
And number two,
like even before I got into privacy,
I haven't celebrated my birthday in like
over a decade.
It's just it's a personal thing.
It's not like religious or anything.
It's just like a personal weird quirk of
mine.
And so like,
I was kind of like offended.
Like I was violently offended that I'm
like, who are you?
And how did you get my birthday?
And I did actually email them and,
or I called them or something.
And I'm like,
where did you get this information?
And they're like, we bought it from Axiom.
And I was just like, okay, what?
Like, yeah.
So that's where a lot of that stuff
comes from.
But yeah.
Yeah,
I was going to say the device thing.
One thing, you know, you did mention that,
yeah,
it could be a lot of money potentially
to have two separate devices and to pay
for a separate phone number.
But one thing that could be underrated is
just holding on to your old devices.
I mean, like, in my personal opinion,
if you have a device that you only
ever turn on once a week and,
you know,
that's your device that you use to check
Instagram or whatever, like,
I think that's a lot better than putting
Instagram on your daily driver.
So...
I don't know.
That's my, maybe, maybe a compromise.
If you can't afford to buy a new,
a new phone or something,
or a second phone,
just hold onto your own old phone when
you upgrade and use it for throwaway
stuff.
That doesn't matter.
So.
Yeah,
someone here also said like Facebook uses
IP for fingerprinting too,
so a separate device wouldn't save that.
Yeah, yeah, definitely.
Like there's all these sort of things.
There's so many vectors that we talk
about.
It's like using a VPN,
making sure that you don't connect.
Like there's all sorts of metadata that
you don't realize that you're sharing that
could connect you straight back, like,
you know,
I'm sure there's some ridiculous thing
that they use like Bluetooth scanning or
Wi-Fi scanning or something like something
really creepy, right?
Or something like that, right?
I can imagine it.
But I think doing the most that we
can from at least the known vectors is
important and using a VPN at the same
time.
on a separate device would definitely be
one of those.
But again,
that also gets tricky because signing up
for accounts with a VPN kind of ties
back into this comment here that we got
from Stan.
When you're using someone else's
infrastructure or like, you know,
number in this case,
there's always the risk that it's tied to
scammers or like, you know,
someone who's abusing signups, right?
So if you use a rented number,
if you use a rented IP address,
you're kind of risking that account
being banned because it's associated with
uh bad activities that someone's used that
IP address or in this case a phone
number to do so um it's kind of
tricky when it comes to that specifically
I think one suggestion that I would have
for like IP addresses is you could try
traveling to like a library hopping on
their free wi-fi creating the account at
the at the library um
Or, you know,
just like McDonald's or whatever.
Any place that has free Wi-Fi, basically.
So that's a way to kind of bypass
that, I guess.
Again, though,
if you connect with a VPN IP address,
it still does associate you with that.
So it's kind of tricky.
And the rented numbers, I would say,
is probably less...
I would probably recommend that less than
just getting an actual SIM card because at
least there's some protection and the
number is actually registered in your name
instead of...
the company kind of proxying it, I guess.
So you don't really own the number in
that case.
So that's where it becomes kind of eh,
because again, you know,
they could revoke the number or like you
said,
it could be used to do illegal stuff.
So it could be blocked on a bunch
of services, which is really annoying.
Yeah, I gotta be honest.
In my experience,
those like disposable number services that
people always talk about online,
they never work for me.
Me personally, I don't know what it is.
I've seen the ones that people like swear
by them.
Like, oh,
I use this to sign up for Discord,
for Twitter,
for like all those companies that are
really strict about using an actual,
like a real phone number.
And I've tried several of them and they
never work for me.
So, but me, like personally, what I,
my main thing with those that I'll say
is,
is I would never use them for anything
actually important.
Like I see people saying like, Oh,
I want to use it for like a,
a throwaway Twitter account or whatever.
And it's like, okay, fine.
If you know, if it,
cause my thing is like,
I don't even think they're going to ban
you because the phone number,
my question is what happens when your
account gets banned and they say, Oh,
we just texted you a code.
And it's like, Oh,
but it was one of those services where
I only have the phone number for like,
you're never going to have access to that
phone number again.
So now you're just locked out.
And if it's again, if it's like, um,
I'm going to be a little bit NSFW
here just for the sake of it.
But if it's the account that you use
on Twitter just to look at porn,
then it doesn't matter.
But if it's your actual Twitter account
that you're using to like build a brand
and you get locked out,
Now what?
You know,
if it's your actual like bank account,
like I've seen people recommend that.
Like, oh,
I'm trying to use this like SMS pool
to sign up for my bank account.
Why?
That's insane.
I've been locked out of my bank account
multiple times for the weirdest stuff for
some reason.
And it's like,
what would I do if it's like, oh,
I can't prove that I own this bank
account.
Like, I don't know.
That just sounds insane to me personally.
I would never use it for anything that
you would be upset losing access to is
the only piece of advice that I'll give
for that.
I know we should move on here in
a minute, but Foundog said,
you can fingerprint based on how many
lines your mouse wheel is configured to
scroll or the mouse acceleration settings
you have configured.
It's wild the things companies can do.
Yeah, and that's what I mean.
Again,
I've seen proofs of concept that
fingerprinting can work with CSS.
I've seen
proofs of concept about fingerprinting um
you know how many uh extensions you have
i know we've talked about that in the
past like it's there's so many different
ways it's one of those things to me
it's one of those things where if you're
not careful you can fall down a rabbit
hole and absolutely stress yourself out
over like oh my god but what if
and it's like but does it really matter
like for some people yes it does again
use tor but like for most of us
it's like it's
I, again, going back to Brett,
this is why I stopped going on Reddit,
but like our slash privacy,
I used to see people like make posts
where they would be having like nuclear
meltdowns because they're like, oh my God,
I logged into Google one time without my
VPN.
Or like I checked Google once or went
to Google search.
How screwed am I?
And it's like, does it,
are you Edward Snowden?
Like,
does it matter if Google got your IP
address once?
It's not the end of the world, man.
Chill.
I don't know.
To me,
there's better ways to spend your energy,
in my personal opinion.
I don't know.
Maybe I'm being a little insensitive,
but that's... Yeah.
What do you mean, Nate?
You've got to disconnect your internet
connection and go live in the middle of
the woods or something?
You know, the more I work in tech,
the more I understand why so many people
do that.
They retire after twenty years in IT,
and they're like,
I'm just going to go live in a
farm,
and
I don't know, man.
I'm going to be honest.
I've worked very hard to create a life
where I can disconnect, and I love it.
Because I am an introvert,
and I do like to...
I know we're really off topic now,
but I'm an introvert.
I love video games.
I love movies,
and I love to stay at home.
But I love the fact that I can
shut everything down and just play video
games.
I don't get notifications.
I don't get emails.
I don't get messages unless they're from
approved contacts.
And it is just so wonderful to...
It's almost as good as touching grass.
And it's like,
I'm just going to go play Jurassic World
Evolution and watch Star Trek.
And that's going to be my evening.
That probably is going to be my evening
tonight, actually.
That's usually what I do.
So it's great.
It's great.
We should all learn how to disconnect from
time to time.
I think I'll,
I'll read this last comment and then we'll
jump into the next story.
Cause we've been on this one for a
minute, but it says, uh, hello.
So that reminds me of how I got
locked out of WhatsApp.
I got curious if I could set up
parental access without some verification
and password.
I entered that I was born zero days
ago and had to upload.
Oh, that's a good one.
That's funny.
Um, yeah, yeah.
That kind of stuff happens, man.
I, um,
Oh, what was it just the other day?
I accidentally,
I've been messing with changing the ports
for SSH just for, you know,
we talked about defense in depth.
I don't rely on security through
obscurity, but it's, you know,
I do the whole, like I disable Rue.
I make it SSH key login,
but I was like, yeah, you know,
I'll stop just like the low level scanners
and stuff.
I'll change the port and like completely
locked myself out of,
I think it was pure tube the other
day.
And then I had to like go to
Hetzner's website and I had to open their
console and I had to like enter the
recovery environment and figure out how to
edit the, oh man, it was nuts.
But yeah,
that's a funny thing about technology is
you can absolutely lock yourself out if
you are not being careful.
But anyways, yeah.
Okay.
With that,
we'll move on to our next story,
which I'm actually kind of excited about
this one personally.
You know, it's funny.
We were just talking about Facebook and
Instagram and metadata and all this kind
of stuff.
And Brave has announced this new feature
that removes the tracking data,
metadata from Instagram and Facebook
photos.
So this is starting in desktop version one
dot nine eight.
And
This is actually really interesting.
So a lot of you guys probably know
that when you take a photo, you know,
on your phone or something for most
people, except for graphene users,
your camera will automatically record a
certain amount of metadata.
And depending on how much access it has,
it could record things like location and
date and time,
or it could just say simple things like,
you know,
a pixel eight a took this camera or
whatever, or photo.
When you upload that online,
Most big tech websites.
And this is the one thing I can
say good about that.
Maybe not the one thing,
but one of the few good things I
can say about them.
Most of them will strip that metadata.
Um,
I wouldn't be surprised if they're
recording it and they're storing it
somewhere on their end,
but at least publicly, you know,
most of the time,
if somebody checks a photo you sent
through discord or.
Facebook or whatever.
As far as I know,
most of the time they won't really be
able to pull that metadata.
This is not so much true on smaller
platforms like Mastodon.
So be mindful.
We definitely encourage you to strip your
own metadata because then the company
can't store it on their end either.
It's definitely a good idea.
But what's interesting is this story is
talking about not that metadata that you
upload,
but apparently when you upload something
to Facebook or Instagram,
there's a uh they add their own piece
of metadata called the um well they don't
know what it's called because facebook
didn't really say here but um they say
they add a value to the special
instructions field that starts with fbmd
and is followed by a long string of
characters and for those of you watching
you can see this right here actually and
uh they say that um
When you download a photo and upload it
again, that value stays the same.
And so even if,
and I'm sure a lot of you guys
have seen this,
if you send like an Instagram link to
a friend, you can,
if you know what you're doing and they
haven't encrypted it,
you can remove the tracking part of that
link.
Um, but what you're,
what they're saying here is like,
let's say you want to get really tricky
with it.
And like,
I don't even want to send this personal
link.
I don't want Facebook to know that I
sent this person.
I'm going to download that picture or
video or whatever,
and then send it directly to them.
When they look at it, Facebook can still,
or if they upload it,
Facebook can still tell because this
freaking thing is buried in the metadata.
So anyways,
Brave has now introduced this new feature
that says when you save an image,
they remove the identifier before the
download finishes.
And when you upload an image,
they upload a clean copy with no metadata
on it.
This is written in C++ with no extra
library.
So it stays small and fast.
And it is posted on GitHub for those
of you who are more technical and want
to check it out.
So yeah,
I guess right now it only works in
Facebook and Instagram.
They say that in the future,
we would like to remove geolocation,
device, date, and time data.
So again, this does not remove everything.
This only removes that one identifier.
So we still recommend things like the
Graphene OS camera, for example,
which automatically removes metadata.
Super convenient.
If you're on an iPhone or you can't
use the Graphene camera for whatever
reason,
a quick and dirty trick is just to
send it to yourself in Signal.
I don't know if that removes everything,
but I know it removes a good chunk
of stuff.
I think there is actually one good
metadata removal tool that I have to go
looking for again.
I can't remember what it is.
But yeah, so again,
this is like a layer of defense.
And they say that they are also planning
to bring this feature to Android and iOS.
And I personally am hoping that they will
bring it to other platforms as well.
I mean,
I don't know how many platforms are
tracking you as aggressively as Meta,
but...
Yeah,
I think that's kind of all I've got
on that one.
I know, Jordan,
you mentioned that it would be really cool
to see other browsers start doing this
kind of stuff, too.
Do you have any thoughts on that?
Every time I hear of Brave adding new
features like this, it's always like, oh,
yeah, this should have just been here.
This should have been by default.
This should have just been the way that
it worked.
It's kind of ridiculous.
I heard they've got this feature called
force paste.
And I'm like,
why doesn't every browser have that?
That's so useful.
Same with this.
It's like,
now you don't have to worry about
uploading and downloading files.
It'll be clean.
It's just the way that it should be
in the first place.
Because again,
I think a lot of the specific metadata
that exists on files is useful when it's
in your library.
When it's in your photo library,
it's like, oh,
I want to know when this picture was
taken.
I want to know all these extra details.
But when you share that photo,
you don't want that extra information to
be shared as well because, you know,
obviously, like, you know,
it's something that is... Oh,
we had a comment here from Firewall's
Don't Stop Dragons.
Exif tool.
I replied to him.
I don't know if that was it.
Maybe.
I think it's a successor to, like,
Scrambled Exif because I don't think that
one's maintained anymore.
So maybe it is Exif tool.
I'd have to go digging around.
I really need to remember, but...
Yeah.
Yeah.
Like you were saying,
like that's brave said that to this data
might have legitimate uses the metadata
you were talking about, for example,
organizing your online photo library.
Like, you know,
some people I don't turn on the location
data, but, you know,
some people go on vacation and turn it
on.
And then like NT, for example,
will automatically group all that together
and be like, oh,
here's your trip to Miami Beach or
whatever.
I don't know.
Don't go to Miami.
I'm biased.
Yeah.
And it's, it's also a safety thing.
And I think a lot of cases,
you know,
that location data is like extremely
problematic, right?
Because if someone has access to that,
you know,
maybe that picture that you took inside
your home,
now they have exact coordinates of where
you live.
So it's,
That is like a pretty big safety concern.
As far as, like you said, though,
as far as we know,
like these big tech companies were not
just like straight up allowing that data
to exist.
Usually they would use it for,
I know Instagram did do this before,
but it would give a rough location.
It would add a location tag to the
specific photo that you post and it
wouldn't be, you know,
a specific location.
like it wouldn't add the actual
coordinates that you took the photo,
right?
It would just be a general location.
So whether they use that for, you know,
I'm sure that, like you said,
they use that for some other tracking
purpose.
I'm sure like, oh,
you took this photo in this specific
location.
Now we know where you've been.
So, yeah,
there's lots of lots of cases where
metadata can can kind of mess you up.
Firewalls don't stop.
Dragon said John McAfee.
I'm not exactly familiar with the John
McAfee situation,
but I assume it was it was related
to like metadata being leaked or something
like that.
That'd be my guess.
Or maybe they were able to figure out
where he was in the photos.
So, I mean,
I know I've said this before, but yeah,
photos are I'm super paranoid about
Um, like again, my last apartment, uh,
that my wife and I,
when we first moved in and we were
kind of figuring out like,
where do we want to put everything?
Like,
where do we want to put our desks
and stuff?
And I remember telling her, I'm like,
I will not have my desk facing out
the window.
Um, because like,
even though it was just a street,
it wasn't like,
like a clearly visible skyline.
It's like, Oh, he lives, you know,
near this city.
But it was like, I just,
I know I've seen,
I think I've told the story about when
I was in Poland, I, um,
I was taking a train and
And I just took a random photo out
from the train and put it in my
signal story.
And one of my friends saw that photo
and to his defense, he's a geo guesser.
He does that for fun, but he instantly,
he's like, Oh,
you're in this town in Poland.
And I'm like, am I?
And I like pulled up the maps and
I looked at it.
I'm like, how did you know that?
And he's like, well, for one,
they have the,
the sidewalk stripes are like unique in
Poland.
And then he's like,
but also that building is like,
I guess like the tallest building in
Poland or something.
And yeah, it's, um,
It's crazy what people can figure out.
Again, I trusted that person,
which is why he had access to that
signal photo.
But people are pretty wild with what they
can pull off a photo.
Kerry said that apparently Vice magazine
posted an image of him when he was
on the lam and didn't strip the GPS
info.
Womp womp.
So again, yeah,
don't depend on Facebook or Vice or
anybody else to strip the metadata for
you.
Make sure you're doing that yourself.
Definitely.
We did get a comment here from hello,
six, four, four, six.
What are your thoughts on Bluetooth
security?
At one point,
would you decide to not use them and
switch to cable connected devices,
which are more secure?
I assume.
I think this also comes down to like
the sort of threats that you're looking
at, right?
I wouldn't use a Bluetooth device for
going on a call,
talking about something confidential.
Because again,
there's like the possibility that someone
could hack that and like get access to,
to the content that's being transmitted,
I think that would be a concern.
But again,
if you're just listening to music or a
podcast or something, it's like,
is the concern super large?
I would say not really.
I think most modern Bluetooth standards
now, they do use encryption and stuff.
So the data is not just completely
accessible to anybody.
But if you mean by specific like security
vulnerabilities,
I think that would be definitely more of
a concern.
But again,
those sort of attacks are relatively rare.
And I think in a lot of cases,
just keeping your device updated and
making sure you're using something that is
like properly supported is the biggest
thing rather than, you know,
trying to be super paranoid about it and
only using cable connected stuff.
I think it is definitely a personal
preference thing.
Some people just really like wired like
headphones and that's fine as well.
So I think you don't have to hack
me.
I am always happy to share what music
I'm listening to or what podcast I'm
listening to.
So you don't have to hack me.
You can just ask.
I don't believe in having guilty
pleasures.
I will openly admit if I'm listening to
pop music or,
true crime or whatever.
I don't care.
That's fair.
And also I think the other thing is
like, uh, it's,
it's also used for like location tracking.
I think, you know,
like you go into stores and like they
have Bluetooth beacons and all sorts of
things like that.
If that's a concern as well,
I could say like, you know, maybe,
maybe don't,
maybe like once you start getting close to
some shops, maybe turn the Bluetooth off.
So that actually, yeah, I did.
I turned off Bluetooth on my pine time.
So at this point,
it's honestly just kind of a fancy watch.
I mean, it wasn't that expensive,
but you know,
originally I bought it cause I wanted the
notifications, but yeah.
And I guess now that,
now that I have this like work from
home job, I try to go,
I try to run my errands in the
middle of the day when like,
there's not as much traffic and hopefully
everybody else is at work.
And I noticed that I actually don't use
headphones as often as I used to.
I think,
just because shopping is not as stressful
as it used to be.
Uh, so yeah, that's,
that's kind of the one thing is like,
I turned the Bluetooth off on this, um,
for the reason you mentioned with the,
the beacons.
And then I have my phone set to
turn off at like a really quick, like,
like, like, like, like, like, like, like,
like, like, like, like, like, like, like,
like, like, like, seconds or something.
Um, the Bluetooth.
So as soon as I get out of
the car,
by the time I get to the door,
it's already off.
So yeah, that's, that's what I do.
But yeah, personally, I, uh,
I'm not great.
I mean, I have sensory issues.
I find going outside can be kind of
loud,
so I wear headphones basically all the
time outside.
It is what it is.
I'm sure that there's a bunch of stores
that know that I go there all the
time because of my Bluetooth beacon.
But like,
am I that worried that they know that
I go there?
Not particularly like, I don't know.
It's just like not the biggest threat to
me, I guess.
It's not like the huge, a massive concern.
Could they like, you know,
if I'm going into a store, there's,
I'm going to be on camera.
I'm particularly, you know, I'm not,
the most normal looking person.
So, uh, you know, if,
if someone sees me on camera,
they're going to know it's me.
Uh, so like, you know,
it's not the biggest concern to me again.
Yeah.
Like I said, like, you know,
the tattoos as well, that's, you know,
things,
there's identifiers about you that are,
that are kind of obvious and that make
you kind of stick out.
And that, that is like,
that's a bigger concern, right?
That would be a more identifying,
identifying than, you know,
being scanned by a Bluetooth beacon.
So, again,
you've got to kind of take your wins
where you're going, right?
I think this sort of thing would be,
like, more of a concern if it's like,
oh, you're going to a protest.
Then I would be like, oh, okay, well,
maybe you should disable it then, right?
Because you probably don't want your
device being scanned then and, you know,
covering up your body and all that.
But, like,
if it's just going to the groceries every
day, it's like...
I don't know.
That's not the biggest threat to me
exactly.
But again,
everyone's threat model is different.
And if it is a concern that people
know where you're going,
then maybe that is something you should be
using wired devices instead.
But again, I'm not sure.
And that's what I was going to say
too, is, you know, it's,
what's important to you.
Like, again,
now that I'm going shopping in the middle
of the day where it's not as crowded,
I don't really need headphones,
but back at my last job when I
would have to go like after work or
on the weekends and it's like super
crowded.
And like,
I don't know what it is with people.
I feel like I've complained about this
before is like,
People become so like low key narcissistic
in grocery stores.
Like they just forget that there's other
people there.
They'll get into the cereal aisle or any
aisle and they'll be in the middle of
the aisle and they'll just stop and stand
there and be like,
which cereal do I want?
And it's like,
there are six people trying to get past
you.
move to one side so people can walk
past you.
And like, I don't know.
It just,
it would make me so angry that like,
that's why I would listen,
like have headphones in is not like a
sensory thing, but it's like, I'm just,
I'm going to listen to music.
I'm going to listen to a podcast.
I'm going to try not to think about
how everybody is forgetting that there's a
hundred and fifty other people in the
store right now and being completely
oblivious.
It's,
yeah so for me like back then it
was totally worth it it's like no i'm
i will lose my mind if i don't
have a distraction from everyone else but
now i don't really need that so yes
it's yeah i don't know i'm with you
it really depends on what's more important
not being tracked or not losing your mind
Yeah,
it's definitely one of those things to
consider.
I guess the other comment we got here
was from someone on YouTube.
They said,
I think Apple forces encryption on
Bluetooth and have for years.
Yeah,
like it is one of these things where,
you know, modern Bluetooth standards,
they're all enforcing encryption and
stuff.
So the content is most likely going to
be fine.
But again, it's like one of those things,
as soon as you start transmitting things
like without a wire,
there's the possibility of it being
intercepted and, you know...
That could be a concern.
It depends, like, you know,
what the concern is because, again, like,
what are you doing?
You're not going to use Wi-Fi then?
Like,
you're just going to have everything be,
like, wired in because of that or, like,
you know, all sorts of, like,
wireless transmissions are happening
everywhere.
So it's one of those personal decisions,
I think.
Agreed.
All right.
I think we got one more forum post
we're going to cover this week.
Uh,
this is actually our last story slash
post.
So if anybody has been holding onto any
questions,
go ahead and drop them in the chat
and, uh,
I will let Jordan take this one.
All right, cool.
Um,
so this one is another one from our
forum that was doing the rounds this week.
The average person not caring about their
online privacy is a good thing.
So, um,
The person said,
I know the title sounds crazy,
but this has been my sentiment as of
lately.
Let me elaborate.
Through my years of casually discussing
computers, privacy,
security with people in real life,
I noticed the total lack of care from
the average Joe,
some even working in IT and cybersecurity.
You point out some very obvious and clear
invasions of their privacy,
and you're met with,
I have nothing to hide.
What is there to steal?
My personal data is of no value.
And just plain old, I don't really care.
This used to bother me lately,
but all my cynicism has adopted.
I have adopted a,
you don't have to outrun the bear.
You just have to be more private and
secure than the average Joe.
The vast majority of people being careless
about their privacy is great for people
who actually care.
It makes authoritative attacks on privacy
tools less aggressive and their nets are
already full.
Um,
so that is definitely an interesting
sentiment, I would say.
Um, I do think it is,
there's something to be said about,
you know,
not being the lowest common denominator,
uh, being just slightly better than, uh,
someone who literally puts zero care in
goes a long way in terms of security,
right?
You know?
the average person just using the same
password on everything,
you've got unique ones on every single
one.
That's a significant security improvement
without much going on, right?
So...
Some counterpoints,
and yet we see many big online platforms
trying to undermine attempts to use their
services privately,
sites that refuse to function if you're
using a VPN or hardened browser,
or at least force you to sign in
if you want to continue.
The vast majority of people not caring
about digital privacy also means less
public support for laws that can protect
your privacy in areas that personal tech
solutions can't.
Everyone else being careless with privacy
also means that they're less likely to
protect your privacy when it's in their
hands.
They may store something sensitive of
yours on iCloud with advanced data
protection turned off or refuse to stop
using invasive hardware or software that
will leak information about your
relationship.
Low adoption doesn't aid the privacy-aware
minority.
On the contrary,
it makes their signature easy to pick out.
So I think there's some valid points in
here that we can pick out.
I think there's kind of pros and cons
to each direction of this, right?
I guess I'll throw it to you, Nate.
Do you agree with this?
I mean, no, I don't.
But to me,
it's one of those – because it's funny.
On my website, on my blog,
I have used that joke about outrunning the
bear several times.
And I use it more as like a
motivational tool for people who are new
to privacy because privacy has the –
first of all privacy gets confused with
anonymity and people keep thinking like oh
i can like never get on the internet
again i have to throw away my phone
i have to go live in a cabin
in the woods i can't stream anymore i
have to switch to arch linux and it's
like privacy is a spectrum like yes if
you throw your phone away and go live
in a cabin in the woods you will
definitely be more private than any of us
here right now but at the same time
it's like you know you could just like
use the Facebook PWA.
Like we just talked about that earlier.
You could use that in brave and that's
going to be a lot more private than
using the Facebook app and things like
that.
And so, um, I, I,
I do use that line,
but I don't think it's a good thing.
I think it's more of a, uh,
a silver lining.
Um,
And yeah, I don't know.
I kind of agree with all the other
points.
It's like,
we have still seen privacy under attack,
even though, you know,
this person said that, you know,
if it makes attacks on privacy less
aggressive, I don't know.
Has anybody been paying attention to chat
control or the flock cameras that have
popped up all over the US?
And that too, like, I think it's,
I know I've said this many times before,
but personally,
I think people do care about privacy.
It's just one of those things where like,
I don't know if it's like a learned
helplessness thing or if people are just
so overwhelmed with everything else they
have going on in their lives,
which I think is totally fair.
But it's one of those things where like
people can only care about so many things.
Like I think all of us would say,
I care about the environment, right?
Like every single one of us.
I don't think there's anyone here who,
I mean,
they might say it as a joke in
the comments,
but I don't think there's anyone here
who's genuinely gonna be like, no,
I hate the planet.
I want the world to burn and flood
and all that.
And yet how many of us have actually
gone to like a privacy protest or
something?
Probably not most of us,
but that doesn't mean we don't care.
It's just that like,
that's not our biggest passion.
That's not, you know,
but we would like maybe sign a petition
or we would like send an email to
our representatives.
And like,
I think everyone's at a different level
where like,
just because somebody isn't willing to,
again, like install cubes on day one,
doesn't mean they don't care about their
privacy, but maybe they don't.
Again, I...
I'm just gonna mention it.
A couple of years ago,
I made a video about PWAs over at
The New Oil.
And the reason I made that video is
because there were literally no videos
about it.
Like when I looked up PWAs,
all I found was technical information for
developers.
And it's like, okay, but what about me?
What about the person who keeps hearing
online that like, hey,
if you use a PWA, it's more private.
I can find like two websites that list
apps that work as a PWA on your
phone.
And that's it.
I can't find anything explaining what they
are or how to use them or anything
like that.
And that's why I made that video.
And I think a lot of people just
fall into that.
I mean,
a lot of people don't fall into that
category of like,
I'm going to go make the thing, but.
You know,
a lot of people like they care,
but they just don't know where to turn.
They don't know that using ProtonMail or
Tudor either or anybody is just like using
Gmail.
It's it's super easy.
They don't know that like a graphene phone
works almost identically to a regular
Android.
They just you know,
I grew up at a time.
Sorry, I know I'm ranting.
I grew up at a time where like
nobody used Linux unless they were a super
nerd developer that hated themselves.
And so I was shocked when I first
started digging into Linux and I'm like,
anybody can use this.
I mean, yeah, at the time,
maybe not like hardcore content creators
and gamers,
but even now it's come so far.
It's like,
you can play most games on Linux.
You know,
the Linux experiment primarily uses Linux
to make his videos.
Like it's come so far now.
It's like, no, it's not like that anymore.
It's not super buggy and super awful.
It's really stable and really polished.
And just, yeah, I don't know.
It's...
I think people do care and I don't
think it's good that they're not acting on
it.
But I mean,
I'll certainly take advantage of it.
It's like a political thing.
Like I may not agree with, you know,
oh,
this politician won and now everybody's
scared they're going to take away guns or
whatever.
I don't agree.
But if I can use that angle to
get you to care about privacy,
I'm not above that.
So.
Yeah, definitely.
I think you brought up some good points.
I think one thing that we've taught,
we've actually already talked about this
before, like at Privacy Guides,
we have an entire section on our website
that Em wrote about basically how to do
this,
how to be like an effective privacy
advocate,
how to be like a privacy activist.
So there's like the Privacy Activist
Toolbox.
And it does literally talk about exactly
what we're talking about right now.
It says, you know,
One specific section was expanding your
perspective.
Don't stop at individual solutions.
Consider the collective impact.
When we think about privacy,
we often focus on the technical tools that
we can use to protect it.
While this is an important component,
it's crucial not to lose sight of how
regulations and invasive practices
impact us collectively.
So there's some really interesting stuff
that's part of that specific section of
that toolbox.
while it might feel easier to focus on
our own needs nobody lives in a vacuum
even if you were able to somehow protect
all the data you have custody of there
is a lot of data about you that
isn't under your control and a lot of
data about others that impact you so you
know everyone you interact with is is
going to be sharing that data um all
sorts of things like that um
And there was another specific section
that I saw that was really good as
well.
Be kind to people,
but relentless with institutions.
So, you know,
obviously saying something to someone
like, oh, you're silly,
you don't know anything,
or like you're being silly by using
Facebook or, you know,
berating someone for using these not
private options isn't...
isn't a good approach, basically.
Use kindness and patience while working
with individuals.
Whenever you talk to individuals,
make sure to stay calm and
kind when communicating with them.
I think aggression or berating somebody
for their actions is definitely not one
way to do that.
But again, it mentions here,
be relentless with corporations,
governments and public institutions.
If there's companies that are abusing your
data, you can be relentless.
You don't have to be kind and respectful.
But, you know, you obviously have to be,
you know, respect,
you have to be respectful and polite when
you're doing that as well.
Like, you know,
don't threaten a company or whatever.
So, yeah, but you can be, you know,
more direct and not as kind.
So definitely think about that when you're
advocating for things.
It's tricky when it comes to the human
factor.
That's always the trickiest because,
you know,
we have all these tools and technical
solutions to things.
But when it comes down to it,
like a lot of the privacy issues that
exist right now are due to, you know,
specific the way that our society
functions, for instance.
Like, you know,
the advertising industry exists because
websites need to make money.
without getting donations or whatever.
So that is one reason why we have
such an issue with websites collecting our
data.
So just be careful when you're interacting
with people because I think
Just caring about yourself and not
worrying about other people is not really
an effective solution in the long run,
is kind of what I was trying to
say.
But hopefully I didn't just ramble too
much there.
I mean, I probably ramble enough.
I think it's okay if other people do.
No,
I'm glad you mentioned the activism
toolbox.
That's privacyguides.org slash activism
for anyone who didn't know.
And yeah, Kerry talks about that too.
Kerry's used that phrase like privacy is a
team sport.
He says, you know,
we all need to care about privacy and
take simple steps because your data
overlaps with my data.
And, you know, that's...
That's something that somebody said in
that forum thread is like, yeah,
if other people don't care about privacy,
I mean,
a lot of us have that issue, right?
You know,
we go to the doctor's office and it's
like, oh,
they're using Zoom for their telehealth
meetings.
Now they're using AI to transcribe stuff
and they don't know.
And, you know, to their defense,
they're so busy, they probably don't care.
But like, you know, you ask the doctor,
where is that being stored?
I don't know.
Go check the privacy policy, which,
you know, just says LOL.
So...
It's a, it is a team sport.
We do need everyone to care.
It's like a, it's like her immunity,
I think is one thing I've compared her
to in the past.
And Stan on Twitter says that a Linux
Mint is so much better than Windows.
I mean,
I think it's just really empowering.
I've told the story before about how years
ago I got my mom to install Linux
Mint and she did it.
pretty much by herself.
She called me.
She's like, I found this old laptop.
I think it was my aunt's laptop.
And it had Windows Vista or something on
it.
And she's like,
I know enough to know that that's outdated
and I shouldn't use it.
And I was like, well, if you're willing,
here's some instructions to install Linux
Min.
And she was able to do it herself
just from text instructions.
Privacy is so much easier in some cases
than people think.
So yeah, it just feels good.
I think it's definitely one of those
situations now.
I'm not sure if we...
We didn't talk about this on this week's
podcast,
but Microsoft had a massive outage
recently.
I think yesterday, most of yesterday.
And I think people started to realize
having that reliance on one specific
company for your operating system,
your word processing application,
your communications platform, your,
I don't know, literally everything.
So that is one of these situations
where...
I'm sure someone running Linux Mint would
be smiling right now because they're not
dealing with this massive, massive outage.
That did happen in the last day.
But again,
it wasn't super related to privacy and
security,
which is why we didn't bring it up.
But I guess I could tie it back
to that a little bit.
Windows users are not having a good time
currently.
Yeah, my sister texted me yesterday.
She's like, what did she ask?
Something about like,
Were you guys affected by the Microsoft
outage?
And I was like, no, absolutely not.
Like, first of all,
we're kind of big tech.
We try to keep our dependence on big
tech services pretty low as it is.
And secondly,
like Jonah is just amazingly good at
sysadmin stuff.
He's been doing it for years,
like even before privacy guides.
And like we self-host probably ninety
percent of our like next cloud and email
and everything.
The only reason I know it's out is
because I see headlines and I see memes.
It was a good week for memes.
Jonah is really on top of it when
it comes to self-hosting stuff for us.
A majority of tools that we use on
the back end is all stuff that he's
set up and it works really well.
It is one of those things where it's
like having that level of control is
definitely...
possible because you know if we're doing
it like hello you know like other people
could probably do it you know like we're
not some massive massive organization
either so again like it is it is
I think it is a wake-up call.
And I really genuinely hope that more
countries,
because a lot of the times it is
government services that are using these
applications, you know,
a lot of Microsoft in government.
So again, it's like,
hopefully it's a wake-up call to them to
be like, oh,
maybe we'll host our own NextCloud
in-house instead, or maybe we'll host,
you know,
only office in the house, you know,
instead to have some sort of
communications platform, you know,
they could host like a gypsy or something.
It would be nice to see people move
more in that direction away from Microsoft
and centralizing so much infrastructure,
especially when it's become such a like
key operating function of your business.
A little concerning.
Yeah.
Like what did people even do when it
went down?
I don't know.
That was funny because, again,
at my last job before Privacy Guides,
I was in the field.
And so I would see on my RSS
feed, it's like, oh,
Microsoft is having an outage.
And I'm like, well,
I guess we're not hearing from the project
managers today.
Good thing we don't really use computers.
We know what we're doing.
So yeah, I don't know.
It's crazy.
Anyways.
That is freaking awesome.
I think that's all we've got,
unless there's anything else you wanted to
add, any last minute thoughts, questions,
comments?
I will just quickly check on the forum
thread that we had.
We did have one forum thread here.
I guess just to quickly mention,
there was someone who did have some, like,
small questions that I thought we'd get to
because they did spend the time to write
up a comment to our thread that we
made.
They mentioned specifically two things.
One was self-hosting against censorship.
There was a story about autosteasy,
which they got –
Basically,
their entire organization got shut down
because they got classified as like a
terrorist organization by the U.S.
government,
which ended up meaning that the main
domain that they had access to got revoked
because basically the registrar, the no,
sorry,
the the top level domain is based in
the U.S.
So basically,
they kind of were forced to withdraw from
access from from that right um and they
suggested you know should they have used a
European domain instead would that have
protected it and you know using a specific
country domain or like Italy which is the
country that Autistica is from would that
have protected them and I just don't think
that's the case I think uh in general
when it when a when a government such
as the United States basically classifies
your organization as a terrorist
organization nobody would wants to touch
you
literally no one wants to do business with
you or interact with you.
I think you would have the same problem
if it was in Europe or if it
was in any country.
It's just the fact that, you know,
the United States has quite a big control
over financial institutions and all sorts
of things like that.
That's why, you know,
sanctions exist and they're so powerful,
right?
Because of that.
So I don't think that would have really
helped a huge amount in that case
specifically.
But again,
I don't think the average person is going
to be prescribed as a terrorist
organization by the US government.
I was honestly so surprised that it even
happened.
So I feel like they're pretty,
pretty niche and somewhat irrelevant,
in my opinion, in the grand scheme of,
you know, internet service.
providers that do like email and stuff but
there was another one here that was about
you didn't get to talk about this because
you wasn't you weren't on that week but
I guess I'll throw it to you did
you have any thoughts on the airplane like
a Doppler curve think question that they
had
Yeah,
I did put this in the show notes
last week, but yeah,
I was busy working on other stuff,
so I don't know if you guys covered
it or not.
But yeah,
the same person was commenting on that
story and said,
I wonder if I would have any airplane
sounds inside.
And from what I understand,
because that was kind of my first thought
too, and...
I did a little bit of research,
which is not super robust.
I wouldn't stake your life on it.
But from what I understand,
if you're inside,
unless you have the windows open,
it's probably not...
probably not going to be to get through
like the,
the installation of your building.
Um,
certainly not in a usable form that would
be useful to this, uh, this attack.
And, uh,
of course me being an audio guy,
my first thought is like,
what about a high pass filter?
Because it said that it used, um, like,
like low frequency sounds that were too
low for humans to hear.
And, uh, personally,
I like to put a high pass on
everybody's voice.
Um, because I just find that
in the podcast I listen to,
the people who don't treat voices at all,
I find I get ear fatigue a lot
faster.
But if they even just basic,
like especially a podcast like this one
where we're just talking,
there's not a lot of music,
there's not a lot of sound effects.
If you can roll off a lot of
that low end,
which shouldn't really be there anyways,
you can listen for longer before your ears
get tired.
Um, so yeah,
apparently a high pass filter would also
work because as the name suggests,
it allows all the high frequencies to pass
and cuts off everything below the filter,
um, which would include things that it's,
it's one of those things that's,
it's more of an advanced,
advanced audio thing where like,
even if you don't consciously hear it,
it like builds up and adds noise.
So yeah.
Um,
If you're a content creator,
use high-pass filters, which, again,
you shouldn't... If it's just you talking,
unless you're like Benedict Cumberbatch or
somebody with a disturbingly deep voice,
it shouldn't really matter anyways.
And if you're recording a band,
you don't need that on the vocals.
You might need it on the kick drum.
And again, if you're doing YouTube,
you add the music in the background,
that's probably not recorded in the same
place.
I don't know.
Yeah.
It seems...
relatively easy.
I don't know if I want to say
easy.
It seems like there are some probably
pretty effective defenses for anyone who's
worried about that.
So that's what I'll say.
Yeah.
And I think it is one of those
scenarios where it's like,
if the CIA wants to find you,
they're going to find you.
Like, I'm sure that there's,
that's one specific method, right?
But I keep seeing more and more,
like that person just kept putting out
more and more videos, like, oh, I,
how I identified someone based on the
lightning strike sounds in the footage.
And it's just like, it's like, okay, like,
you know,
it's getting a little ridiculous,
but it's like, okay, like,
that is one of these things where,
you know,
there's always evolving techniques to
extract more information from things.
And it's like,
as long as we're staying like somewhat on
top of things, um,
I feel like for the average person,
it's not a concern.
But again,
like if someone really wants to find you
and you post an image or some audio
or something like that,
I'm sure there's ridiculous ways that they
can use to get access to your location.
But again, like unless someone's super,
super wants to find out where you live,
then probably not a great concern, right?
Yeah,
that's kind of how I feel is like
there's,
it just, to me,
it feels like if you play the what
if game forever, you,
you would just become paralyzed.
Like, you know, we,
we live in a world, like you said,
we're like any video,
they can pick out the freaking,
the sidewalk stripe,
the cross crosswalk stripes.
As you're driving by,
they can pick out the skyline.
Now we have, you know,
they can pick you out through the wifi
signals through walls.
And it's just like, if,
If we just try to defend against
everything, I mean,
that's threat modeling, right?
That's on the EFF's page.
Trying to defend against everything all
the time is impossible and exhausting.
And so it's like, pick the big things.
Like, okay,
don't post a picture of the skyline in
a unique city where somebody could easily
triangulate where you are.
You know, don't...
things like that like don't post a selfie
where your mail is visible in the
background with your address on it or your
work shirt where people can tell where you
work you know I don't know it's trying
to take care of the things that you
can actually do something about and that
are most likely to be abused I think
so at least that's what I try to
focus on otherwise I will just spiral into
paranoia and anxiety and get nothing done
so I will say there's also the alternative
which is don't share it in the first
place
You don't need to share everything that
you do with everybody.
It is one of those things where less
is more, I guess.
Just don't share as much stuff.
Don't share so many things on the
internet.
Then you don't have to worry about, oh,
is this audio file that I shared going
to have the information in there?
Don't share any audio files.
Don't share any photos unless you really
need to.
And if it's with someone that you trust,
again, be careful.
I think posting things publicly,
you do start having those issues where
people will be super creepy.
FirewallstoneStopDragon said,
with AI and all ground level maps,
locating someone based on the background
in the image is going to be scary
good.
Automated OSINT.
Yeah,
I think that sort of stuff does exist
already at this point, right?
Like, you know,
identifying people based on really weird
stuff like, oh,
the picture you took in your hotel room,
I worked out exactly which hotel you're
staying at and which exact room that
you're staying at because of the photos
that I found of the rooms on the
internet.
And then I
located that to where you're staying.
There's creepy stuff that AI can do,
and it automates a lot of the busy
work that these attacks require,
which I think is definitely super scary.
Yeah, for sure.
I like what you said about don't put
it out there in the first place.
Leave some mystery.
It's okay to not exist a hundred percent
online.
Have some mystery in the world.
The world needs more mystery.
Definitely.
I'm not seeing too many questions here
that we could cover.
So I guess we can kind of start
heading out to the outro now,
unless you had anything you wanted to add.
I think I'm good.
Alrighty then.
So all the updates from this week in
privacy will be shared on the blog every
week.
So sign up with the newsletter or
subscribe with your favorite RSS reader.
If you want to stay tuned,
we also offer a podcast which is available
on all podcast platforms.
and RSS,
which now includes video on supportive
platforms.
And this video will also be synced to
PeerTube.
Privacy Guides is an impartial nonprofit
organization that is focused on building a
strong privacy advocacy community and
delivering the best digital privacy and
consumer technology rights advice on the
internet.
If you want to support our mission,
then you can make a donation on our
website at privacyguides.org slash donate.
You can make a donation on any page
on the website by clicking the red heart
icon located in the top right corner of
the page.
You can contribute using standard fiat
currency via debit or credit card or opt
to donate anonymously using Monero or with
your favorite cryptocurrency.
Becoming a paid member unlocks exclusive
perks like early access to video content,
exclusive video content,
and priority during the This Week in
Privacy livestream Q&A.
You'll also get a cool badge on your
profile in the Privacy Guides forum and
the warm,
fuzzy feeling of supporting independent
media.
Thanks for watching,
and we'll see you next week.